Manuel B. Garcia

Manuel B. Garcia serves as the Senior Director for Educational Technology and Digital Learning at FEU Institute of Technology, Manila, Philippines. Read More

Contact Info

1607, FEU Tech Building,
P. Paredes St, Sampaloc,
Manila, Philippines
mbgarcia@feutech.edu.ph

Follow Me

The Complete Library

All Research Guides

Browse every published guide in the Researcher's Field Guide, including the complete research journey and supplemental collections, listed alphabetically for quick reference.

Complete Library

Every published guide

Showing 4,001–4,050 of 5,065 guides

5,065 guides
PART 02 · SUBPART 16 · GUIDE 305

Should You Read Every Citation?

Should You Read Every Citation in an Important Paper?

Even an important paper rarely requires reading every item in its reference list. Follow the citations that carry consequential claims, define key methods, reveal competing evidence, or lead you to literature your own work depends on.

PART 02 · SUBPART 16 · GUIDE 304

When to Read the Statistical Analysis Plan

When Should You Read the Statistical Analysis Plan?

A statistical analysis plan can show how researchers intended to analyze their data before the final results were interpreted. It becomes particularly useful when analytical flexibility, prespecification, or deviations could affect your appraisal.

PART 02 · SUBPART 16 · GUIDE 303

When to Read the Study Protocol

When Should You Read the Study Protocol Alongside the Final Paper?

A protocol can show what researchers intended to do before the final results were known. Comparing it with the published paper is especially useful when prespecification, methodological changes, outcome selection, or analytical flexibility could affect your interpretation.

PART 02 · SUBPART 16 · GUIDE 302

When to Read Supplementary Material

When Should You Read the Supplementary Material?

You do not need to read every supplementary file attached to every paper. Read it when information outside the main article could materially change your understanding, appraisal, reproduction, or use of the study.

PART 02 · SUBPART 16 · GUIDE 301

Can Reading the Conclusion First Bias You?

Can Reading the Authors' Conclusion First Bias How You Interpret the Study?

Reading the conclusion first can frame your expectations before you inspect the evidence. That does not automatically make your interpretation biased, but it gives you a reason to check the authors' claims independently against the study's methods and results.

PART 02 · SUBPART 16 · GUIDE 299

Abstract Before Figures and Tables?

Should You Read the Abstract Before Looking at the Figures and Tables?

Reading the abstract first gives you useful orientation, but it also gives you the authors' interpretation before you inspect the evidence. The best reading order depends on whether you are screening a paper or critically evaluating its results.

PART 02 · SUBPART 16 · GUIDE 298

How to Remember Why a Research Paper Mattered

How Do You Avoid Forgetting Why a Paper Was Important Six Months Later?

Remembering a paper is less important than being able to recover why it mattered. Leave a compact retrieval trail that records its contribution, relevance to your work, key evidence, limitations, connections, and what you intended to do with it.

PART 02 · SUBPART 16 · GUIDE 297

What to Extract From Every Research Study

What Information Should You Extract From Every Study You Read?

Do not extract everything simply because it appears in the paper. Capture the study's question, context, design, sample or data, relevant measures or procedures, findings, limitations, and why the study matters to your research.

PART 02 · SUBPART 16 · GUIDE 296

How to Take Notes on a Research Paper

How Do You Take Notes Without Rewriting the Entire Paper?

Good research notes are not miniature copies of the papers you read. Record what you will need later: the study's question, relevant evidence, limitations, your interpretation, and why the paper matters to your research.

PART 02 · SUBPART 16 · GUIDE 295

When You Don’t Understand the Methods or Analysis

What Should You Do When You Don’t Understand the Methods or Analysis?

You do not need to master every unfamiliar method before you can learn from a paper. First identify exactly what you do not understand, determine whether it matters to your purpose, and investigate it deeply enough to interpret the evidence responsibly.

PART 02 · SUBPART 16 · GUIDE 294

How to Read Outside Your Discipline

How Do You Read a Paper Outside Your Own Discipline?

A paper outside your discipline can be difficult even when you are an experienced researcher. Build enough disciplinary context to understand the question, terminology, methods, evidence, and assumptions that matter to why you are reading it.

PART 02 · SUBPART 16 · GUIDE 293

Should You Trust the Discussion?

Should You Trust the Authors’ Interpretation in the Discussion?

The discussion deserves serious attention, but it is the authors' interpretation of the evidence rather than the evidence itself. Compare its major claims with the results, methods, limitations, and plausible alternative explanations before accepting them.

PART 02 · SUBPART 16 · GUIDE 291

When to Read the Methods Section Closely

When Should You Read the Methods Section Closely?

You do not need to scrutinize the methods of every paper during your first pass. Read them closely when your interpretation, citation, methodological decision, or confidence in a finding depends on how the evidence was produced.

PART 02 · SUBPART 16 · GUIDE 290

How Much of a Research Paper Do You Need to Understand?

How Much of Every Paper Do You Actually Need to Understand?

You do not need the same depth of understanding for every research paper you encounter. The more consequential the paper is to your argument, methodology, or interpretation, the more deeply you need to understand the parts on which you rely.

PART 02 · SUBPART 16 · GUIDE 289

Is This Paper Worth Reading in Full?

How Do You Decide Whether a Paper Is Worth Reading in Full?

Not every paper you find deserves the same amount of attention. Screen its relevance first, then consider whether the evidence, methods, and role it may play in your research justify a deeper reading.

PART 02 · SUBPART 16 · GUIDE 288

Where Should You Start Reading a Research Paper?

Abstract, Methods, Results, or Discussion: Where Should You Start?

There is no single best section to start with in every research paper. The abstract is useful for orientation, but your next move should depend on whether you need context, methodological detail, evidence, or interpretation.

PART 02 · SUBPART 16 · GUIDE 287

What to Read First in a Research Paper

What Should You Read First When You Open a Research Paper?

Start by orienting yourself to what the paper studies and whether it is relevant to your purpose. The title and abstract are usually useful first stops, but what you read next should depend on what you need from the paper.

PART 02 · SUBPART 16 · GUIDE 286

Do You Have to Read a Paper From Start to Finish?

Do You Have to Read a Research Paper From Beginning to End?

You rarely need to read every research paper from the first word to the last. The depth and order of your reading should depend on why you opened the paper and what you need to learn from it.

PART 02 · SUBPART 16 · GUIDE 285

How to Read a Research Paper Efficiently

How to Read a Research Paper Efficiently Without Reading Every Word

You rarely need to read every research paper from the first word to the last. Learn a practical multi-pass method for deciding what deserves attention, extracting the important evidence, and knowing when a paper requires a deeper read.

PART 02 · SUBPART 15 · GUIDE 283

Multiple Papers From the Same Dataset

Can the Same Dataset Produce Many Papers That Look Like Independent Evidence?

Large cohorts, registries, surveys, and administrative databases can generate many papers without generating equally many independent participant populations. Learn how to distinguish legitimate dataset reuse from independent replication.

PART 02 · SUBPART 15 · GUIDE 282

Preprints and Published Versions

Can Preprints and Published Versions Accidentally Be Counted Twice?

A preprint and a later journal article may be separate reports of the same underlying study. Learn how to link versions, inspect meaningful changes, and avoid treating one study as two independent pieces of evidence.

PART 02 · SUBPART 15 · GUIDE 278

Using Companion Papers Without Double-Counting

How Do You Use Companion Papers Without Double-Counting Participants?

Companion papers can contain valuable outcomes, methods, harms, and follow-up data that the main publication omits. The key is to use those reports as sources for one study without treating their shared participants as independent evidence.

PART 02 · SUBPART 15 · GUIDE 277

Identifying the Primary Study Report

How Do You Decide Which Publication Is the Primary Report?

When one study has several publications, the primary report is usually the report chosen as the main source for study results, not simply the first or most cited paper. Learn how to make and document that choice.

PART 02 · SUBPART 15 · GUIDE 275

Overlapping Study Populations

What Is an Overlapping Study Population, and Why Does It Matter?

An overlapping study population occurs when two or more studies or analyses include some of the same individuals. Learn why this creates dependence and how to recognize and manage it in evidence synthesis.

PART 02 · SUBPART 15 · GUIDE 274

Identifying the Same Participants Across Papers

How Do You Know Whether Two Papers Use the Same Participants?

Two papers can use some or all of the same participants even when their titles, outcomes, authors, or sample sizes differ. Learn how to detect shared samples before treating papers as independent evidence.

PART 02 · SUBPART 15 · GUIDE 273

Identifying Papers From the Same Study

How Do You Know Whether Two Papers Report the Same Study?

Two papers are not necessarily two independent studies. Learn how to compare study identifiers, participants, recruitment periods, settings, methods, and other clues to determine whether publications report the same underlying study.

PART 02 · SUBPART 14 · GUIDE 272

Recording “Maybe” Studies During Screening

Should You Record “Maybe” Studies Separately During Screening?

A temporary “maybe” category can help when eligibility cannot yet be determined, but it should represent unresolved information rather than become a permanent third eligibility category.

PART 02 · SUBPART 14 · GUIDE 271

Handling Borderline Studies

How Do You Handle Borderline Studies Without Making Arbitrary Decisions?

Borderline studies should not be decided by instinct alone. Identify the exact source of uncertainty, apply predefined criteria consistently, document clarifications, and use adjudication when reasonable reviewers could disagree.

PART 02 · SUBPART 14 · GUIDE 270

Right Outcome, Different Population

Should You Include a Study With the Right Outcome but Different Population?

A study does not become eligible simply because it measures exactly the outcome you need. Whether a different population can be included depends on how your population was defined and whether eligible participants can be identified separately.

PART 02 · SUBPART 14 · GUIDE 269

Right Population, Wrong Outcome

Should You Include a Study With the Right Population but Wrong Outcome?

A study with the right population but a different outcome is not automatically irrelevant. Whether it belongs depends on whether outcomes are part of your eligibility criteria, which varies by review question and methodology.

PART 02 · SUBPART 14 · GUIDE 266

When a Paper Title Is Misleading

What Should You Do When the Title Is Misleading?

A misleading title should not decide whether a study is included or excluded. Screen against your eligibility criteria using the abstract and, when necessary, the full text.

PART 02 · SUBPART 14 · GUIDE 264

When to Use a PRISMA Flow Diagram

When Does Study Selection Need a PRISMA Flow Diagram?

A PRISMA flow diagram is designed to show how records identified through a systematic search moved through screening, retrieval, eligibility assessment, and final inclusion. It is appropriate for systematic reviews and many structured evidence syntheses, but not automatically for every literature review.

PART 02 · SUBPART 14 · GUIDE 263

Do You Need Two Literature Screeners?

Do You Need Two People to Screen the Literature?

Two reviewers are often used to reduce errors and individual judgment in study selection, but the requirement depends on the review methodology and screening stage. Learn when independent duplicate screening is expected and what “two reviewers” actually means.

PART 02 · SUBPART 14 · GUIDE 262

Tracking Reasons for Study Exclusion

How Do You Keep Track of Why Studies Were Excluded?

A good exclusion record shows how potentially relevant studies moved from consideration to exclusion. Learn what reasons to record, when detailed documentation is needed, and how to keep those decisions consistent and auditable.

PART 02 · SUBPART 14 · GUIDE 260

Multiple Papers From the Same Study

How Do You Handle Multiple Papers From the Same Study or Dataset?

One study can produce several papers, and those papers should not automatically be counted as separate studies. Learn how to link related reports, combine their information, and prevent the same participants or data from influencing your review more than once.

PART 02 · SUBPART 14 · GUIDE 259

Research From Different Countries or Populations

Should You Exclude Research From a Different Country or Population?

A study should not be excluded merely because it comes from another country or a somewhat different population. The relevant question is whether those differences matter enough to the review question to affect eligibility or how the evidence should be interpreted.

PART 02 · SUBPART 14 · GUIDE 258

Should You Exclude Old Studies?

Should You Exclude a Study Just Because It Is Old?

A study should not usually be excluded merely because it is old. A publication-date restriction is most defensible when time itself has a meaningful relationship to the review question, evidence, technology, policy, or context.

PART 02 · SUBPART 14 · GUIDE 256

Changing Inclusion Criteria After Screening

Can You Change Your Inclusion Criteria After Screening Has Started?

Inclusion criteria can sometimes be changed after screening begins, but not simply because the studies you found are inconvenient. Any amendment should remain faithful to the review question, avoid being driven by study findings, and be documented transparently.