Manuel B. Garcia

Manuel B. Garcia serves as the Senior Director for Educational Technology and Digital Learning at FEU Institute of Technology, Manila, Philippines. Read More

Contact Info

1607, FEU Tech Building,
P. Paredes St, Sampaloc,
Manila, Philippines
mbgarcia@feutech.edu.ph

Follow Me

The Complete Library

All Research Guides

Browse every published guide in the Researcher's Field Guide, including the complete research journey and supplemental collections, listed alphabetically for quick reference.

Complete Library

Every published guide

Showing 4,501–4,550 of 5,065 guides

5,065 guides
PART 01 · SUBPART 27 · GUIDE 566

Replicating a Study After a Failed Replication

Should You Replicate a Study That Has Already Failed to Replicate?

A failed replication does not necessarily end the scientific question. Another replication can be valuable when it can distinguish among plausible explanations for the disagreement rather than merely adding a third result to an unresolved dispute.

PART 01 · SUBPART 27 · GUIDE 565

Replicating a Study Without Independent Replication

Should You Replicate a Study That Has Never Been Independently Replicated?

A study that has never been independently replicated may be a strong replication candidate, particularly when an important claim depends heavily on it. Lack of independent replication creates an evidential gap, but it does not automatically make every unreplicated study worth repeating.

PART 01 · SUBPART 27 · GUIDE 564

Replicating a Study Without Original Data

Should You Replicate a Study Whose Original Data Are Unavailable?

Original data can be extremely useful when planning and interpreting a replication, but replication normally generates new data rather than reanalyzing the original dataset. The more important question is whether the published methods and available materials provide enough information to conduct an interpretable new test.

PART 01 · SUBPART 27 · GUIDE 563

Replicating a Methodologically Weak Study

Should You Replicate a Study With Serious Methodological Weaknesses?

A methodologically weak study can deserve replication, especially when its claim matters and remains influential. The challenge is deciding whether repeating the original design would test the finding or merely reproduce the weakness that made the evidence uncertain.

PART 01 · SUBPART 27 · GUIDE 562

Replicating a Widely Accepted Finding

Should You Replicate a Finding That Is Already Widely Accepted?

Wide acceptance does not make a scientific finding permanently exempt from replication. The relevant question is whether another replication could resolve meaningful uncertainty that the existing evidence has not already addressed.

PART 01 · SUBPART 27 · GUIDE 561

Replicating Consequential Findings With Weak Evidence

Should You Replicate a Finding That Has Major Consequences but Weak Evidence?

A finding may deserve replication precisely because people are making important decisions from evidence that remains uncertain. The stronger the consequences of being wrong, the stronger the case for rigorous independent verification, provided the replication can genuinely improve the evidence.

PART 01 · SUBPART 27 · GUIDE 560

Which Study Should You Replicate?

Which Study Should You Replicate When Several Findings Need Verification?

When several findings could benefit from verification, the best replication target is not necessarily the most famous or easiest study. A defensible choice weighs how much uncertainty the replication could resolve against the importance, consequences, and feasibility of testing the finding.

PART 01 · SUBPART 27 · GUIDE 559

How to Justify a Replication Study

How Do You Justify a Replication Without Pretending It Is Completely Novel?

A replication does not need a completely new research question to make a contribution. A strong justification explains which existing claim remains uncertain, why resolving that uncertainty matters, and how the new study provides evidence the literature does not yet have.

PART 01 · SUBPART 27 · GUIDE 558

Can a Failed Replication Be Valuable?

Can a Failed Replication Still Be Valuable Research?

A replication does not become worthless when the original finding does not recur. An informative non-replication can reduce confidence in a claim, expose possible boundary conditions, improve effect estimates, and identify questions that the original study could not answer.

PART 01 · SUBPART 27 · GUIDE 557

When Exact Replication Is Impossible

What Should You Do When You Cannot Reproduce the Original Study Exactly?

No replication can reproduce every feature of an earlier study exactly. The practical task is to preserve the conditions needed to test the original claim, justify unavoidable changes, and report them clearly enough for readers to judge what the new evidence means.

PART 01 · SUBPART 27 · GUIDE 556

Is a Weak Study Worth Replicating?

Is Replicating a Weak Study Worthwhile?

A weak original study can make replication more valuable because its claim remains uncertain, but weakness alone is not a reason to replicate it. First decide whether the underlying claim matters and whether your new study can provide substantially more informative evidence.

PART 01 · SUBPART 27 · GUIDE 554

Replicating an Already Replicated Study

Can You Replicate a Study That Was Already Replicated Successfully?

One successful replication does not permanently settle a scientific claim. Another replication can still be valuable when important uncertainty remains, although its value depends on what new evidence the additional study can provide.

PART 01 · SUBPART 27 · GUIDE 552

Adding a Variable to a Replication

When Does Adding a New Variable Turn a Replication Into an Extension?

Adding a variable does not automatically turn a replication into an extension. The key question is what the variable does: does it help you retest the original claim, or does it introduce an additional claim that the original study never examined?

PART 01 · SUBPART 27 · GUIDE 551

Replication vs. Extension Study

Replication vs. Extension Study: What’s the Difference?

A replication asks whether prior evidence or a previous claim holds up under another test. An extension moves beyond that prior work to investigate something additional, although a single study can deliberately do both.

PART 01 · SUBPART 27 · GUIDE 550

Direct vs. Conceptual Replication

Direct vs. Conceptual Replication: Which Question Are You Actually Trying to Answer?

Direct and conceptual replications do not simply differ in how much of the original method they copy. They can address different evidential questions: whether a finding recurs under closely similar conditions or whether the underlying claim survives a meaningfully different test.

PART 01 · SUBPART 27 · GUIDE 549

When Is Replication More Useful?

When Is Replication More Useful Than Starting Something New?

Replication may be more useful than starting something new when an important claim remains uncertain and another independent test could materially improve what researchers know. The strongest replication targets combine meaningful consequences with unresolved evidence.

PART 01 · SUBPART 26 · GUIDE 547

Methodological Thinking Before Research Design

How Much Methodological Thinking Is Necessary Before Part 4 Research Design Begins?

You should not fully design the study while developing the research question, but you cannot ignore methodology either. Before detailed design begins, you need enough methodological thinking to know that the question is answerable, feasible, ethical, and capable of being matched with suitable evidence.

PART 01 · SUBPART 26 · GUIDE 546

When an Available Dataset Drives the Question

When Does “I Have This Dataset” Become a Poor Reason for Choosing a Research Question?

Existing datasets can support valuable research at far lower cost than collecting new data, and questions can legitimately emerge from exploring what those datasets contain. The problem begins when researchers confuse “this can be analyzed” with “this question needs to be answered.”

PART 01 · SUBPART 26 · GUIDE 545

When an Available Tool Starts Driving the Question

When Does “I Have This Tool” Become a Poor Reason for Choosing a Research Question?

Access to a research tool can make a project easier, cheaper, and more feasible, but availability does not establish that the tool measures what your question requires. The warning sign is when the question begins changing primarily to justify using what you already have.

PART 01 · SUBPART 26 · GUIDE 541

When Your Institution Cannot Support the Method

Should You Abandon a Question If It Requires a Method Your Institution Cannot Support?

A method being unavailable at your institution does not necessarily make the research question unworkable. Before abandoning it, determine whether the missing capacity can be accessed elsewhere, developed through collaboration, or addressed without compromising the question.

PART 01 · SUBPART 26 · GUIDE 540

When Adapting a Research Question Goes Too Far

When Does Adapting the Question to the Available Method Go Too Far?

Research questions often need refinement once practical constraints become clear. The problem begins when adaptation no longer makes the original question feasible but instead replaces it with a different, less meaningful question simply because it fits the method you can use.

PART 01 · SUBPART 26 · GUIDE 539

When the Best Research Method Is Unavailable

What Should You Do When the Best Method for the Question Is Not Available to You?

The ideal method for a research question may be beyond your current resources, expertise, access, or institutional capacity. The solution is not automatically to abandon the question or substitute whatever method is convenient, but to determine what can change without changing what the study actually claims to answer.

PART 01 · SUBPART 26 · GUIDE 538

Can You Start With the Method?

Can You Start With a Preferred Method and Then Find a Question for It?

Starting with a preferred method is not automatically wrong, but the final study should not exist merely to give that method something to do. A defensible research question must matter independently and require evidence the chosen method can appropriately provide.

PART 01 · SUBPART 26 · GUIDE 537

Should You Use a Method You Already Know?

Should You Choose a Method Because You Already Know How to Use It?

Knowing a research method well is a genuine advantage, but familiarity should not be the main reason you choose it. The method must first be capable of producing the evidence needed to answer your research question.

PART 01 · SUBPART 25 · GUIDE 534

When Does a Time Delimitation Need Justification?

When Should a Time Delimitation Be Justified?

A study period needs scientific justification when time affects what can be observed, compared, or inferred. The relevant question is not simply how long data collection takes, but whether the chosen period matches the phenomenon and research question.

PART 01 · SUBPART 25 · GUIDE 533

When Does a Geographic Delimitation Need Scientific Justification?

When Should a Geographic Delimitation Be Scientifically Justified Rather Than Merely Convenient?

A convenient study location is not automatically a methodological problem. Stronger scientific justification becomes necessary when characteristics of place could affect the phenomenon, the evidence collected, or the population and settings to which the findings are intended to apply.

PART 01 · SUBPART 25 · GUIDE 532

When Does a Population Boundary Raise a Generalizability Question?

When Should a Population Delimitation Become a Separate Research Question About Generalizability?

A population delimitation becomes a substantive generalizability question when extending findings beyond the studied population matters and there are plausible reasons the findings may differ in the target population. The issue is not simply who was excluded, but whether that exclusion changes the inference you want to make.

PART 01 · SUBPART 25 · GUIDE 531

Should You State What the Study Will Not Answer?

Should You Define What the Study Will Not Attempt to Answer?

You do not need to list everything a study will not investigate. However, explicitly defining consequential boundaries can prevent readers from attributing questions or claims to the study that its design was never intended to address.

PART 01 · SUBPART 25 · GUIDE 530

Can Research Scope Be Too Broad Despite Adequate Resources?

Can a Scope Be Too Broad Even When the Sample Size and Resources Are Adequate?

Adequate sample size, funding, time, and expertise do not automatically make a broad research scope appropriate. A study can be feasible yet still combine too many questions, constructs, populations, or analytical purposes to form one coherent investigation.

PART 01 · SUBPART 25 · GUIDE 527

Should the Question or Feasibility Define the Scope?

Should the Scope Be Defined by the Question or by What You Can Realistically Study?

Your research question should establish what the study needs to investigate, but feasibility determines what you can responsibly promise to answer. The strongest scope is usually developed by refining the question and practical constraints together.

PART 01 · SUBPART 25 · GUIDE 526

When Does One Study Become Several?

When Does Expanding the Scope Turn One Study Into Several Studies?

One study begins to look like several when its questions require substantially independent populations, evidence, methods, analyses, or conceptual rationales and no longer need to be answered together. Related questions can belong to the same research program without being forced into a single study.

PART 01 · SUBPART 25 · GUIDE 525

How to Prevent Research Scope Creep

How Do You Prevent “Scope Creep” Once the Project Is Underway?

Research scope creep occurs when new questions, variables, populations, methods, analyses, or other demands gradually enter a project without sufficient reconsideration of its original purpose and capacity. Prevent it by making the baseline scope explicit and requiring every proposed addition to justify both its intellectual value and its methodological cost.

PART 01 · SUBPART 25 · GUIDE 524

When Available Data Narrow Your Scope

What Should You Do When Your Available Data Force You to Narrow the Scope?

If available data cannot support the original scope, do not force them to answer a broader question than they can address. Determine what evidence the question actually requires, assess whether other data can provide it, and narrow or reformulate the question transparently when necessary.

PART 01 · SUBPART 25 · GUIDE 523

Can Research Scope Change?

Can the Scope Change After the Study Has Started?

A study's scope can sometimes change after research has begun, but the later the change occurs, the more carefully its methodological, ethical, analytical, and reporting consequences must be considered. Legitimate revisions should be documented transparently rather than rewritten as though they had always been planned.

PART 01 · SUBPART 25 · GUIDE 522

Should Research Exclusions Be Explained?

Should You Explain Why Certain Variables or Populations Were Excluded?

Consequential exclusions should usually be explained when readers need the rationale to understand or evaluate the study. The explanation should identify why the population or variable was excluded and what that decision means for the evidence and conclusions.

PART 01 · SUBPART 25 · GUIDE 521

When Is a Research Question Too Narrow?

When Does Narrowing the Scope Make the Research Question Too Trivial?

A research question becomes too narrow when its boundaries make the study manageable but remove so much uncertainty, variation, significance, or applicability that answering it contributes little. The goal is not maximum breadth, but a focused question whose answer still matters.

PART 01 · SUBPART 25 · GUIDE 520

When Does Narrowing Scope Improve Research?

When Does Narrowing the Scope Improve a Study?

Narrowing the scope can improve a study when it removes unnecessary complexity while preserving what is needed to answer the research question. The goal is not a smaller study for its own sake, but a more coherent match among the question, evidence, methods, and claims.

PART 01 · SUBPART 25 · GUIDE 519

Can Research Exclusions Be Justified?

Can Excluding a Population or Variable Be Methodologically Justified?

Excluding a population or variable can be methodologically justified when the exclusion follows from the research question, protects participants, improves measurement or comparability, or serves another defensible design purpose. The key question is what the exclusion does to the evidence and the conclusions you intend to draw.

PART 01 · SUBPART 25 · GUIDE 518

What Should You Leave Out of a Study?

How Do You Decide What to Deliberately Leave Out of a Study?

Leave something out of a study when it is not necessary to answer the research question, falls outside the phenomenon or population of interest, or adds complexity without sufficient methodological value. Exclusion should sharpen the inquiry without removing evidence the study actually needs.

PART 01 · SUBPART 25 · GUIDE 517

What Is a Research Delimitation?

What Is a Delimitation, and Why Isn’t It Automatically a Weakness?

A delimitation is a boundary deliberately established by the researcher to define what a study will and will not investigate. A well-justified delimitation can strengthen a study by keeping its question, evidence, and claims coherent rather than attempting to cover every possibility.

PART 01 · SUBPART 25 · GUIDE 516

What Should Your Research Scope Specify?

Population, Place, Time, Variables, and Context: What Should Your Scope Specify?

Population, place, time, variables, and context are common dimensions of research scope, but they are not five boxes every study must fill. Specify the boundaries that materially determine what your research question covers and how its findings should be understood.