Manuel B. Garcia

Manuel B. Garcia serves as the Senior Director for Educational Technology and Digital Learning at FEU Institute of Technology, Manila, Philippines. Read More

Contact Info

1607, FEU Tech Building,
P. Paredes St, Sampaloc,
Manila, Philippines
mbgarcia@feutech.edu.ph

Follow Me

The Complete Library

All Research Guides

Browse every published guide in the Researcher's Field Guide, including the complete research journey and supplemental collections, listed alphabetically for quick reference.

Complete Library

Every published guide

Showing 3,651–3,700 of 5,065 guides

5,065 guides
PART 02 · SUBPART 42 · GUIDE 651

Unanswered Questions From Inconsistent Evidence

What Questions Remain Unanswered Because Evidence Is Inconsistent?

Conflicting findings do not simply mean that researchers need one more study. Learn how to identify the question hidden inside inconsistent evidence and investigate why results differ.

PART 02 · SUBPART 42 · GUIDE 649

Unanswered Questions From Narrow Populations

What Questions Remain Unanswered Because Populations Are Too Narrow?

Evidence from a narrow population may answer a question well for that group while leaving its applicability elsewhere uncertain. Learn when population differences create a meaningful research gap.

PART 02 · SUBPART 42 · GUIDE 646

Unanswered Questions From Weak Evidence

What Questions Remain Unanswered Because the Evidence Is Weak?

A question can remain unanswered even when several studies have examined it. The important task is to identify exactly how weak evidence limits the conclusions researchers can reasonably draw.

PART 02 · SUBPART 41 · GUIDE 640

When the Best Evidence Comes From Another Discipline

What Should You Do When the Strongest Evidence Comes From a Different Discipline?

The strongest evidence for your research question may sit outside the literature your discipline usually reads. Use it when it genuinely bears on the question, while examining whether its concepts, methods, populations, and assumptions transfer to your context.

PART 02 · SUBPART 41 · GUIDE 636

When Your Research Problem May Not Exist

What Should You Do When the Literature Suggests Your Research Problem May Not Exist?

A research problem should not survive simply because you have already designed a study around it. If the literature suggests the problem may not exist, verify what the evidence actually establishes before deciding whether to narrow, reframe, or abandon the idea.

PART 02 · SUBPART 40 · GUIDE 634

The Skeptical Reader Test

What Would a Skeptical Reader Say You Left Out?

Before finalizing a literature review, imagine a knowledgeable reader who does not share your conclusion. What important evidence, qualification, or alternative explanation would they immediately notice is missing?

PART 02 · SUBPART 40 · GUIDE 631

Changing Search Terms and Confirmation Bias

Can Changing Search Terms After Seeing the Literature Introduce Confirmation Bias?

Changing search terms after seeing initial results is not automatically biased. Literature searching is often iterative, but revisions can introduce confirmation bias when they increasingly retrieve evidence that supports an emerging conclusion while neglecting plausible alternatives.

PART 02 · SUBPART 40 · GUIDE 629

Including Strong Contradictory Studies

Should You Include Strong Studies That Undermine Your Argument?

Strong evidence does not become less relevant because it complicates your argument. If a credible study falls within the scope of your review, its implications should be confronted rather than minimized, hidden, or excluded.

PART 02 · SUBPART 40 · GUIDE 628

Including Weak Supportive Studies

Should You Include Weak Studies That Support Your Argument?

A weak study should not become stronger simply because it supports your argument. Whether it belongs in a review depends on the review's eligibility criteria, while how much it should influence the conclusion depends on what its weaknesses mean for the evidence.

PART 02 · SUBPART 40 · GUIDE 627

Avoid Dismissing Contradictory Studies

How Do You Avoid Dismissing Contradictory Studies Too Quickly?

A contradictory study may be flawed, irrelevant, or genuinely important. Before dismissing it, determine whether its limitations actually explain the disagreement or whether the study is exposing a weakness in your emerging conclusion.

PART 02 · SUBPART 40 · GUIDE 626

Avoid Favoring Studies That Agree With You

How Do You Avoid Giving More Attention to Studies That Agree With You?

A literature review can become biased even when contradictory studies are included. The problem may be unequal attention: supportive evidence gets explored, explained, and remembered while conflicting evidence receives much less serious treatment.

PART 02 · SUBPART 40 · GUIDE 623

Cherry-Picking in Literature Reviews

What Is Cherry-Picking in a Literature Review?

Cherry-picking occurs when a literature review selectively emphasizes evidence that supports a preferred conclusion while neglecting relevant evidence that complicates or contradicts it. Learn how it happens and how to reduce the risk.

PART 02 · SUBPART 39 · GUIDE 622

When the Original Source Does Not Support the Claim

What Should You Do When the Original Source Does Not Support the Widely Repeated Claim?

Sometimes a claim is repeated throughout the literature even though the source commonly cited for it does not actually provide the claimed evidence. The next step is not simply to reject the claim, but to determine what the source supports, whether other direct evidence exists, and where the mismatch arose.

PART 02 · SUBPART 39 · GUIDE 621

Can a Repeated Claim Have Little Evidence?

Can a Frequently Repeated Claim Have Surprisingly Little Direct Evidence?

A claim can appear throughout a research literature while resting on only a small number of studies that directly tested it. Tracing citations helps separate repetition of a claim from independent evidence supporting it.

PART 02 · SUBPART 39 · GUIDE 619

Does the Review Misrepresent the Study?

How Do You Detect When a Review Misrepresents a Primary Study?

A review can cite the correct study yet describe its findings inaccurately or too strongly. Detecting misrepresentation requires comparing the review's exact claim with the primary study's design, measures, results, and qualifications.

PART 02 · SUBPART 39 · GUIDE 618

When Should You Read the Original Study?

When Is It Necessary to Read the Original Study Rather Than a Review Citing It?

Reviews are excellent for understanding a body of evidence, but they cannot always substitute for the original study. When your argument depends on a particular study's methods, numbers, findings, or limitations, the primary paper usually deserves a closer look.

PART 02 · SUBPART 39 · GUIDE 617

Should You Trace Claims to the Original Source?

Should You Trace Important Claims Back to the Original Source?

Important claims are often worth tracing back to the source that generated the evidence. Doing so helps you distinguish original findings from later interpretations and detect changes that may have entered through citation chains.

PART 02 · SUBPART 39 · GUIDE 616

What Is a Citation Cascade?

What is a Citation Cascade?

A citation cascade traces how a publication is cited directly and then indirectly through later generations of papers. It can reveal how scholarly influence travels, but the size of a cascade should not be confused with the strength of evidence behind a claim.

PART 02 · SUBPART 39 · GUIDE 614

What Is Citation Distortion?

What Is Citation Distortion, and How Does It Spread Through a Literature?

Citation distortion occurs when later scholarship represents a source in a way that changes or overstates what it actually supports. Repeated citation can then carry the altered claim through a literature until its evidential origin becomes difficult to see.

PART 02 · SUBPART 38 · GUIDE 612

When There Is No Stable Consensus

What Should You Say When the Field Genuinely Has No Stable Consensus?

When a field genuinely lacks stable consensus, say so clearly, but do not translate disagreement into “we know nothing.” Identify what is established, what remains contested, why the disagreement persists, and what evidence could resolve it.

PART 02 · SUBPART 38 · GUIDE 611

When Minority Evidence Cannot Be Ignored

When Does Ignoring Minority Evidence Become Unjustified?

Minority evidence does not deserve special status merely because it challenges consensus, but neither can it be dismissed by head count. It becomes consequential when its quality or implications could materially alter the prevailing conclusion.

PART 02 · SUBPART 38 · GUIDE 609

Representing Scientific Disagreement

How Do You Represent Scientific Disagreement Proportionately?

Representing scientific disagreement proportionately does not mean giving every position equal space. It means matching the prominence and certainty of each position to its evidential support and relevance.

PART 02 · SUBPART 38 · GUIDE 608

Can a Majority Suppress Uncertainty?

Can a Dominant Majority Suppress Legitimate Scientific Uncertainty?

Scientific consensus can be well justified while still leaving room for legitimate uncertainty. The challenge is recognizing when a dominant position appropriately reflects the evidence and when it prematurely marginalizes credible alternatives.

PART 02 · SUBPART 38 · GUIDE 607

Can a Vocal Minority Distort Consensus?

Can a Vocal Minority Make a Settled Field Appear Deeply Divided?

A highly visible minority can make scientific disagreement appear larger than it is. The relevant question is not how loudly competing positions are expressed, but how much credible evidence and expert support each position actually has.