Manuel B. Garcia

Manuel B. Garcia serves as the Senior Director for Educational Technology and Digital Learning at FEU Institute of Technology, Manila, Philippines. Read More

Contact Info

1607, FEU Tech Building,
P. Paredes St, Sampaloc,
Manila, Philippines
mbgarcia@feutech.edu.ph

Follow Me

The Complete Library

All Research Guides

Browse every published guide in the Researcher's Field Guide, including the complete research journey and supplemental collections, listed alphabetically for quick reference.

Complete Library

Every published guide

Showing 1,601–1,650 of 5,065 guides

5,065 guides
PART 05 · SUBPART 12 · GUIDE 222

When Protection Becomes Unfair Exclusion

When Does Protecting a Population Become Unfairly Excluding Them From Research?

Protection becomes unfair exclusion when researchers remove a population more broadly than the actual risk requires, particularly when reasonable safeguards could permit participation and the resulting evidence is intended to apply to the people being left out.

PART 05 · SUBPART 12 · GUIDE 221

When Research Exclusion Becomes Unethical

Can Excluding Vulnerable Participants From Research Also Be Unethical?

Excluding participants who may be vulnerable can reduce risk in some studies, but exclusion is not ethically neutral. When people are routinely left out, research may produce evidence that does not apply to them while denying them fair access to participation and its possible benefits.

PART 05 · SUBPART 12 · GUIDE 220

Research Ethics With Refugees and Migrants

What Ethical Issues Arise When Research Involves Refugees, Migrants, or People With Precarious Legal Status?

Refugee, migrant, or precarious legal status does not automatically eliminate autonomy, but it can make disclosure, institutional contact, dependency, and misunderstanding unusually consequential. Ethical research requires particular care with consent, language, recruitment, data collection, and what participation may reveal.

PART 05 · SUBPART 12 · GUIDE 219

Research Ethics and Economic Disadvantage

What Ethical Issues Arise When Research Involves Economically Disadvantaged Participants?

Economic disadvantage can shape the meaning of incentives, the burden of participation, and who researchers find easiest to recruit. Ethical protection requires attention to voluntariness and fair compensation, but also to justice: disadvantaged communities should not become convenient sources of research burdens while others receive the benefits.

PART 05 · SUBPART 12 · GUIDE 217

Research Ethics With Patients

What Ethical Issues Arise When Research Involves Patients or People Receiving Care?

Patients can participate voluntarily in research, but receiving care can create dependencies and expectations that complicate consent. Researchers need to distinguish clinical care from research, address therapeutic misconception, and ensure that treatment relationships do not make participation feel obligatory.

PART 05 · SUBPART 12 · GUIDE 216

Research Ethics With Older Adults

What Ethical Issues Arise When Research Involves Older Adults?

Older age alone does not establish vulnerability, incapacity, or a need for surrogate consent. Ethical research with older adults requires attention to individual capacity, health and functional differences, accessibility, dependency, study burden, and the consequences of excluding older people from evidence intended for them.

PART 05 · SUBPART 12 · GUIDE 215

Extra Protections for Children in Research

What Extra Protections Are Needed When Research Involves Children?

Research involving children often requires protections beyond those used for competent adults, including attention to parental permission, child assent, risk, and the child's developing autonomy. The exact requirements depend on the research, the child's capabilities, applicable law, and the governing ethical framework.

PART 05 · SUBPART 12 · GUIDE 214

Research With Impaired Decision-Making Capacity

Can Researchers Include Participants With Impaired Decision-Making Capacity?

Impaired decision-making capacity does not automatically require exclusion from research. Inclusion may be ethically permissible when scientifically justified and accompanied by protections appropriate to the participant's capacity, the study's risks, and applicable law.

PART 05 · SUBPART 12 · GUIDE 213

Stigma, Legal Status, and Research Risk

Can Social Stigma or Legal Status Make Participation Unusually Risky?

A study can be physically low risk yet carry serious social or legal consequences if participation or sensitive information becomes known. When stigma or legal status matters, researchers need to examine not only what they collect but what disclosure could mean for the people behind the data.

PART 05 · SUBPART 12 · GUIDE 211

Financial Need and Undue Influence

Can Financial Need Make a Participant Vulnerable to Undue Influence?

Financial need can make a research offer especially attractive, but neither poverty nor payment automatically establishes undue influence. Researchers need to examine the offer, the study, participants' circumstances, and whether incentives compromise voluntary decision-making.

PART 05 · SUBPART 12 · GUIDE 210

Can Research Design Create Vulnerability?

Can Researchers Create Vulnerability Through the Way a Study Is Designed?

Vulnerability is not always something participants bring into a study. Recruitment methods, incentives, privacy practices, authority relationships, and other design choices can create or intensify vulnerabilities that might otherwise have been absent.

PART 05 · SUBPART 12 · GUIDE 209

Vulnerability and Informed Consent Capacity

Does Vulnerability Automatically Mean Someone Cannot Give Informed Consent?

A research participant can be vulnerable and still be fully capable of providing informed consent. Vulnerability, decision-making capacity, and voluntariness are related ethical concerns, but they are not interchangeable.

PART 05 · SUBPART 12 · GUIDE 208

Does Vulnerable Group Membership Always Mean Vulnerability?

Does Belonging to a Vulnerable Group Automatically Make Someone Vulnerable in Every Study?

Membership in a group commonly described as vulnerable can signal ethical concerns that deserve attention, but it does not necessarily establish the same vulnerability for every member in every study. Researchers should determine what actually creates vulnerability in the particular research context.

PART 05 · SUBPART 12 · GUIDE 207

Is Vulnerability Personal or Situational?

Is Vulnerability a Characteristic of a Person or a Situation?

Research vulnerability is not necessarily a permanent characteristic of a person. It can emerge, disappear, or change when circumstances, relationships, research procedures, or risks change.

PART 05 · SUBPART 12 · GUIDE 206

What Vulnerability Means in Research Ethics

What Does “Vulnerable” Actually Mean in Research Ethics?

In research ethics, vulnerability is better understood as an increased likelihood of being wronged or harmed in a particular research context, not simply as membership in a named group. Identifying vulnerability means asking what makes a participant less able to protect their interests and how the research context contributes.

PART 05 · SUBPART 12 · GUIDE 205

Protecting Vulnerable Research Participants

Research With Vulnerable Participants: What Extra Protections Are Needed?

Vulnerability does not automatically mean that someone should be excluded from research or cannot provide informed consent. The appropriate protections depend on what makes participants susceptible to harm or wrong and how the study can reduce that vulnerability without unfairly excluding them.

PART 05 · SUBPART 11 · GUIDE 204

When to Disclose Participant Payment

Should Participant Payment Be Mentioned Before or After the Risks of the Study Are Explained?

Research guidance requires participants to receive clear information about payment and study risks, but it does not establish a universal rule that one must always be disclosed before the other. The stronger principle is appropriate context: payment should be visible without overshadowing the information participants need to evaluate the study.

PART 05 · SUBPART 11 · GUIDE 203

Noncash Research Incentives

Can Gifts, Food, Transportation, or Other Noncash Benefits Create Undue Influence?

Noncash benefits can create undue influence just as monetary incentives can, but not every gift, meal, or transportation benefit is an incentive. Researchers should first identify whether the benefit reimburses a cost, facilitates participation, expresses appreciation, or provides a net inducement.

PART 05 · SUBPART 11 · GUIDE 201

Course Credit as a Research Incentive

Is Course Credit an Ethical Incentive for Student Participants?

Course credit can be used as a research incentive, but students must not be placed in a position where research is effectively the only practical way to earn the credit. A comparable non-research alternative and protection against academic penalties are central to voluntariness.

PART 05 · SUBPART 11 · GUIDE 200

Prize Draws as Research Incentives

Can Prize Draws or Lotteries Be Used as Research Incentives?

Prize draws can sometimes be used to encourage research participation, but they are not simply a cheaper substitute for guaranteed compensation. Researchers must consider ethical review, transparent odds and prize terms, local gambling or sweepstakes law, and whether participants should receive reimbursement or compensation independently of the drawing.

PART 05 · SUBPART 11 · GUIDE 199

Payment for Careless Survey Responses

Can Researchers Refuse Payment When Survey Responses Appear Careless or Unusable?

Researchers should not refuse payment merely because survey responses are inconvenient, unexpected, or subjectively judged to be poor. Objective, prospectively defined evidence that a participant did not meaningfully perform the required task may support rejection in some studies or platforms, but the criteria should be defensible and applied consistently.

PART 05 · SUBPART 11 · GUIDE 198

Withholding Payment for Noncompliance

Can Researchers Withhold Payment From Participants Who Do Not Follow Study Instructions?

Researchers may establish legitimate payment conditions tied to required study activities, but payment should not become an improvised punishment for noncompliance. The key questions are what the payment represents, what the participant actually completed, and what conditions were disclosed and approved in advance.

PART 05 · SUBPART 11 · GUIDE 196

Payment After Participant Withdrawal

Should Participants Still Be Paid if They Withdraw Before Completing the Study?

Participants who withdraw generally should not lose reimbursement or compensation already accrued through participation. A genuine completion incentive may be treated differently, but withdrawal should not erase payment associated with costs already incurred or contributions already made.

PART 05 · SUBPART 11 · GUIDE 195

Different Participant Payment Amounts

Is It Ethical to Pay Different Participants Different Amounts for the Same Study?

Different payment amounts are not automatically unethical, but equal participation generally supports equitable compensation. Differences can be justified when participants incur different expenses, undertake different activities or burdens, or participate in locations with meaningfully different monetary contexts.

PART 05 · SUBPART 11 · GUIDE 194

Payment for Riskier Research

Should Participants Be Paid More for Riskier Research?

Riskier research does not automatically justify higher participant payment. Research risk must first be ethically acceptable independently of payment, and major ethics frameworks differ on whether accepting risk itself should increase compensation.

PART 05 · SUBPART 11 · GUIDE 193

What Should Participant Payment Reflect?

Should Participant Payments Reflect Time, Inconvenience, Risk, or All Three?

Time and inconvenience are widely recognized bases for participant compensation, while reimbursement addresses expenses. Risk is more controversial: authoritative ethics frameworks differ on whether payment should compensate participants for accepting research risk.

PART 05 · SUBPART 11 · GUIDE 192

Large Payments and Coercion

Does a Large Payment Automatically Make Participation Coercive?

A large payment can strongly influence someone's decision to participate without coercing them. In research ethics, coercion ordinarily involves a threat, while attractive offers are more appropriately examined for possible undue influence.

PART 05 · SUBPART 11 · GUIDE 191

Research Incentives and Undue Influence

When Does an Incentive Become Undue Influence?

An incentive becomes ethically concerning not merely because it influences participation, but when the offer may compromise a person's adequate consideration or understanding of important study information. Context, payment structure, consent, and participant circumstances all matter.

PART 05 · SUBPART 11 · GUIDE 190

How Much Participant Payment Is Too Much?

How Much Participant Payment Is Too Much?

There is no universal monetary threshold at which research participant payment becomes ethically excessive. The amount must be evaluated in context, including what the payment is for, what participation requires, and whether an incentive could interfere with adequately considered voluntary consent.

PART 05 · SUBPART 11 · GUIDE 189

What Participant Payment Compensates For

What Is Participant Payment Actually Supposed to Compensate For?

Participant payment can recognize time, effort, inconvenience, and other burdens, while reimbursement separately addresses study-related expenses. A defensible payment plan begins by identifying what participants actually contribute or incur.

PART 05 · SUBPART 11 · GUIDE 187

Paying Research Participants

Can Researchers Pay People to Participate in Research?

Researchers can generally pay people for participating in research, but payment must be ethically justified, transparently disclosed, and reviewed where required. The key question is not simply whether participants are paid, but how the payment is structured and whether participation remains voluntary.

PART 05 · SUBPART 10 · GUIDE 185

Eligible but Not Selected for Research

Can Researchers Tell Someone They Were Eligible but Not Selected for a Study?

Being eligible for a study does not necessarily guarantee enrollment. Researchers can often tell someone that they will not be enrolled, but what else should be disclosed depends on the approved selection process, screening information, privacy obligations, study design, and whether detailed explanation could be misleading or compromise the research.

PART 05 · SUBPART 10 · GUIDE 184

When Participants Think Research Is Mandatory

What Should Researchers Do When Potential Participants Believe Participation Is Mandatory?

If potential participants believe research is mandatory when it is actually voluntary, researchers should correct the misunderstanding before obtaining consent and investigate what created it. Repeating the word “voluntary” may not be enough if the recruitment process itself communicates something different.

PART 05 · SUBPART 10 · GUIDE 183

Mandatory Research Participation

Can an Organization Require Employees or Students to Participate in Research?

An organization cannot make voluntary research participation compulsory simply by calling it a course requirement or workplace task. The answer depends first on whether the activity is actually research, then on the applicable consent rules, alternatives, penalties, and ethics-review framework.

PART 05 · SUBPART 10 · GUIDE 182

Gatekeeper Pressure in Research

Can Gatekeepers Create Pressure to Participate Even When Researchers Do Not?

Researchers can design a perfectly voluntary invitation and still end up with pressured participants if a manager, teacher, clinician, community leader, or other gatekeeper presents participation as expected. Researchers need to manage not only what gatekeepers permit, but what they communicate and what they learn about individual participation.

PART 05 · SUBPART 10 · GUIDE 181

Power Differences and Voluntary Participation

How Do Power Differences Affect Whether Participation Is Truly Voluntary?

Power differences do not automatically make research participation involuntary, but they can change the consequences participants associate with saying no. Researchers should examine who controls valued resources, decisions, information, and future opportunities rather than looking only for explicit threats.

PART 05 · SUBPART 10 · GUIDE 180

Perceived Coercion in Research

Can Someone Feel Coerced Even When the Researcher Never Explicitly Pressures Them?

A researcher does not have to threaten someone for participation to feel compulsory. Perceived pressure can arise from authority, dependency, social expectations, timing, setting, or uncertainty about what will happen after refusal, even when the researcher sincerely intends participation to be voluntary.

PART 05 · SUBPART 10 · GUIDE 179

Recruitment by Supervisors or Teachers

Is It Ethical for Supervisors or Teachers to Recruit People Over Whom They Have Authority?

A research invitation changes when it comes from someone who can grade, evaluate, reward, discipline, recommend, or otherwise influence the recipient's future. Authority does not always prohibit recruitment, but it can make refusal costly enough that additional safeguards become necessary.

PART 05 · SUBPART 10 · GUIDE 178

Recruiting Friends, Family, or Colleagues

Can Researchers Ask Friends, Family Members, or Colleagues to Participate?

Friends, relatives, and colleagues are not automatically excluded from research participation. Personal relationships can, however, introduce loyalty, obligation, awkwardness, privacy concerns, and subtle influence that researchers need to address before treating familiar people as convenient participants.

PART 05 · SUBPART 10 · GUIDE 177

Recruiting Clients or Service Users

Can Researchers Recruit Their Own Clients or Service Users?

Clients and service users may sometimes participate in research conducted by people or organizations that serve them, but dependency can make refusal difficult. Researchers need to separate research participation from access to services, benefits, case decisions, and the ongoing professional relationship.

PART 05 · SUBPART 10 · GUIDE 176

Recruiting Your Own Patients

Can Clinicians Recruit Their Own Patients for Research?

Clinicians may sometimes recruit their own patients, but the clinical relationship can complicate voluntary consent. Patients may interpret a research invitation as medical advice or worry that refusal could affect their care, making independence and clear separation between research and treatment especially important.

PART 05 · SUBPART 10 · GUIDE 175

Recruiting Employees or Subordinates

Can Researchers Recruit Their Own Employees or Subordinates?

Employees and subordinates may sometimes participate in research conducted within their workplace, but employment relationships can make refusal difficult. Researchers need to address authority, confidentiality, incentives, perceived job consequences, and what managers can learn about participation.

PART 05 · SUBPART 10 · GUIDE 174

Recruiting Your Own Students

Can Researchers Recruit Their Own Students?

Researchers are not automatically prohibited from recruiting their own students, but the teacher-student relationship can make a voluntary invitation difficult to separate from academic authority. Recruitment, course incentives, privacy, and who knows who participated may therefore require additional safeguards.

PART 05 · SUBPART 10 · GUIDE 173

Information Before Research Participation

How Much Can You Tell Potential Participants Before They Decide Whether to Join?

Potential participants need enough relevant information to make an informed decision, but not every detail has to appear in the first recruitment message. The amount, timing, and organization of disclosure depend on whether researchers are recruiting interest, seeking informed consent, or using an ethics-approved alteration of consent.