Manuel B. Garcia

Manuel B. Garcia serves as the Senior Director for Educational Technology and Digital Learning at FEU Institute of Technology, Manila, Philippines. Read More

Contact Info

1607, FEU Tech Building,
P. Paredes St, Sampaloc,
Manila, Philippines
mbgarcia@feutech.edu.ph

Follow Me

The Complete Library

All Research Guides

Browse every published guide in the Researcher's Field Guide, including the complete research journey and supplemental collections, listed alphabetically for quick reference.

Complete Library

Every published guide

Showing 1,451–1,500 of 5,065 guides

5,065 guides
PART 05 · SUBPART 21 · GUIDE 372

Privacy Risks Created by Data Linkage

Does Data Linkage Create New Privacy Risks Even When Each Dataset Was Safe on Its Own?

Two datasets that present modest privacy risks separately can become substantially more revealing when linked. Researchers should reassess identifiability, sensitivity, access, disclosure, and security after linkage rather than relying on the protections applied to each source alone.

PART 05 · SUBPART 21 · GUIDE 371

Linking Datasets Without Recontacting Participants

Can Researchers Link Different Datasets Without Recontacting Participants?

Researchers can sometimes link datasets without recontacting participants, but there is no automatic permission to do so. Consent scope, identifiability, linkage purpose, legal authority, ethics review, and safeguards determine whether linkage can proceed.

PART 05 · SUBPART 21 · GUIDE 370

Does De-Identification Make Secondary Use Ethical?

Does De-Identification Automatically Make Secondary Use Ethically Acceptable?

De-identification can substantially reduce privacy risks and may change how secondary research is regulated, but it does not automatically make every secondary use ethically acceptable. Consent commitments, purpose, residual risks, governance, and potential harms can still matter.

PART 05 · SUBPART 21 · GUIDE 369

When Original Consent Is Unclear

What Should You Do When the Original Consent Does Not Clearly Cover Your New Study?

When original consent does not clearly cover a proposed secondary study, ambiguity should not automatically be interpreted as permission or prohibition. Reconstruct the original authorization, assess the proposed use, and obtain the appropriate ethics or institutional determination before proceeding.

PART 05 · SUBPART 21 · GUIDE 368

Ethics of Using Archived Research Data

What Ethical Responsibilities Come With Using Archived Research Data?

Archived research data may be scientifically valuable long after the original study ends, but depositing data in an archive does not erase researchers' ethical responsibilities. Secondary users need to understand the data's provenance, authorization, restrictions, privacy risks, and governance before reuse.

PART 05 · SUBPART 21 · GUIDE 367

Consent to Unimagined Future Research

Can Participants Meaningfully Consent to Research Uses That Have Not Yet Been Imagined?

Participants can sometimes meaningfully authorize categories of future research even when individual studies have not yet been imagined. Meaningful consent does not require perfect prediction, but it does require honest uncertainty, understandable boundaries, genuine choice, and credible governance.

PART 05 · SUBPART 21 · GUIDE 366

What Is Broad Consent?

What Is Broad Consent, and How Broad Can Consent Really Be?

Broad consent allows participants to authorize certain future secondary uses of their data or biospecimens without consenting separately to every future study. It can be broad, but it is not ethically equivalent to unlimited permission.

PART 05 · SUBPART 21 · GUIDE 365

How Far Can Secondary Research Move From Original Consent?

How Far Can Secondary Research Move From the Purpose Participants Originally Consented To?

Secondary research does not have a universal permitted distance from the purpose participants originally accepted. The relevant boundary depends on the scope of consent, reasonable expectations, the nature and consequences of the new use, and the applicable ethical and legal framework.

PART 05 · SUBPART 21 · GUIDE 364

Reusing Data for a Different Research Question

Can Data Collected for One Study Be Used to Answer a Different Research Question?

Data collected for one study can sometimes be used to answer a different research question. The new analysis must be methodologically defensible, ethically permissible, and consistent with applicable consent, governance, and data-use requirements.

PART 05 · SUBPART 21 · GUIDE 363

Does Secondary Data Research Need New Consent?

Does Secondary Data Research Need New Consent?

Secondary data research does not automatically require researchers to obtain consent again. The answer depends on what participants originally authorized, whether the data remain identifiable, the proposed secondary use, and the applicable ethical and legal framework.

PART 05 · SUBPART 20 · GUIDE 357

Researcher Identity in Online Observation

Should Researchers Identify Themselves When Observing Online Groups?

Researchers should generally be transparent about their research role when interacting with online communities, but disclosure is not identical across every observational design. Public unobtrusive observation and justified covert research require different ethical reasoning.

PART 05 · SUBPART 20 · GUIDE 356

Online Community Research Ethics

What Ethical Issues Arise When Research Involves Online Communities?

Research involving online communities raises ethical questions about privacy, consent, researcher presence, community norms, group harms, quotations, access, and reporting. A community is more than a convenient collection of posts.

PART 05 · SUBPART 20 · GUIDE 355

Paraphrasing Online Posts

Should Researchers Paraphrase Online Posts to Reduce Searchability?

Paraphrasing online posts can reduce the chance that published research leads readers back to the original author, but it is not always methodologically appropriate. Researchers must balance protection from identification against preserving the evidence their analysis actually requires.

PART 05 · SUBPART 20 · GUIDE 353

Quoting Social Media Posts

Do Researchers Need Permission to Quote Social Media Posts?

Researchers do not necessarily need the author's permission every time they quote a social media post, but public availability does not settle the issue. Ethical permission, identifiability, copyright, platform rules, and research consent are separate questions.

PART 05 · SUBPART 20 · GUIDE 352

Internet Users: Participants or Data Sources?

Are Internet Users Human Research Participants or Data Sources?

Internet users are not automatically research participants simply because researchers analyze something they created online, nor does calling them data sources eliminate ethical responsibilities. Their status depends on the research design and the framework governing the study.

PART 05 · SUBPART 20 · GUIDE 350

Public Social Media as Research Data

Does a Public Social Media Post Automatically Count as Public Research Data?

A publicly visible social media post may qualify as public information under some research frameworks, but that does not make every research use ethically equivalent. Researchers should examine context, privacy expectations, sensitivity, identifiability, scale, and how the material will be reported.

PART 05 · SUBPART 20 · GUIDE 349

Using Online Data Without Consent

Can Researchers Use Websites, Forums, and Social Media Posts Without Consent?

Researchers may sometimes use publicly available online information without obtaining individual consent, but online accessibility does not settle the ethical question. Context, user expectations, sensitivity, identifiability, scale, quotation, and the method of collection all matter.

PART 05 · SUBPART 20 · GUIDE 348

Covert Observation Ethics

When Is Covert Observation Ethically Defensible?

Covert observation can sometimes be ethically defensible when disclosure would make important research impracticable, but methodological convenience is not enough. Researchers must justify the concealment, minimize risk, protect privacy, and follow applicable ethics requirements.

PART 05 · SUBPART 20 · GUIDE 347

Observing Children and Vulnerable People

Does the Ethical Boundary Change When Observation Involves Children or Vulnerable People?

Observational research involving children or people in vulnerable circumstances may require protections beyond those appropriate for other populations. Researchers should assess consent capacity, assent, power, privacy, risk, and applicable regulatory safeguards rather than relying on public visibility alone.

PART 05 · SUBPART 20 · GUIDE 346

Recording People in Public

Can Researchers Record People in Public Without Telling Them?

Recording people in public can sometimes be ethically permissible without prior individual consent, but recording creates risks beyond ordinary observation. Privacy, identifiability, harm, recording method, data security, and applicable ethics and legal requirements all matter.

PART 05 · SUBPART 20 · GUIDE 345

Research in Public Places

Does Being in a Public Place Mean Someone Can Be Studied Without Consent?

Being in a public place does not amount to consent to participate in research. Some low-risk public observation may proceed without individual consent, but only when the research satisfies the relevant ethical and institutional conditions.

PART 05 · SUBPART 20 · GUIDE 344

Public vs. Private Behavior

Public vs. Private Behavior: Where Is the Ethical Boundary for Observation?

The ethical boundary between public and private behavior is not determined solely by where an observation occurs. Researchers must consider reasonable expectations of privacy, context, identifiability, sensitivity, and how observations will be recorded and reported.

PART 05 · SUBPART 20 · GUIDE 343

Observation Without Consent

Can Researchers Observe People Without Their Consent?

Researchers can sometimes observe people without obtaining individual consent, but the ethical acceptability depends on privacy expectations, risk, identifiability, research design, and applicable ethics requirements.

PART 05 · SUBPART 19 · GUIDE 342

Is Covert Observation Deception?

Is Covert Observation a Form of Deception?

Covert observation does not automatically involve active deception because researchers may observe without making any false statement to participants. It can still raise substantial ethical questions about consent, privacy, identifiability, researcher participation, risk, and debriefing.

PART 05 · SUBPART 19 · GUIDE 341

Can Researchers Ever Skip Debriefing?

Can Researchers Ever Decide Not to Debrief Participants?

Researchers cannot simply decide that debriefing is unnecessary after deception. Some ethics frameworks recognize limited circumstances in which debriefing or particular information may be omitted, but the exception requires justification and appropriate ethics review.

PART 05 · SUBPART 19 · GUIDE 340

When Debriefing Could Cause More Harm

What Happens When Debriefing Could Cause More Harm Than the Original Deception?

Debriefing is meant to correct deception, but disclosure can occasionally create greater harm than the false or incomplete belief it would correct. In such cases, researchers may need an ethics-approved modified, delayed, or exceptionally limited debrief rather than assuming that complete immediate disclosure is always safest.

PART 05 · SUBPART 19 · GUIDE 339

Can Participants Withdraw Data After Deception?

Can Participants Withdraw Their Data After Learning They Were Deceived?

Participants may have an opportunity to withdraw their data after learning about deception, but the rule is not identical across ethics frameworks. Whether withdrawal remains possible can also depend on whether researchers can still identify and remove the participant’s data.

PART 05 · SUBPART 19 · GUIDE 338

Can Research Debriefing Be Delayed?

Can Debriefing Be Delayed Until the Entire Study Is Finished?

Debriefing can sometimes be delayed until data collection is complete when earlier disclosure would genuinely compromise ongoing research. The delay should be prospectively justified and reviewed, with particular attention to what participants will continue believing and whether waiting could cause harm.

PART 05 · SUBPART 19 · GUIDE 337

When Should Research Debriefing Occur?

How Soon After Participation Should Debriefing Occur?

Debriefing should generally occur as soon as the scientific reason for withholding information has ended, particularly when participants remain under a false belief. Some studies may justify delayed disclosure, but the delay should itself be ethically reviewed rather than treated as the default.

PART 05 · SUBPART 19 · GUIDE 336

What Should a Research Debrief Explain?

What Should a Good Research Debrief Actually Explain?

A good research debrief does more than reveal that deception occurred. It should explain the study’s actual purpose, identify what was false or withheld, explain why the alteration was necessary, correct important misconceptions, and communicate any participant options required by the governing ethics framework.

PART 05 · SUBPART 19 · GUIDE 335

Research Debriefing Requirements

What Is Debriefing After Deception or Incomplete Disclosure, and When Is It Required?

Debriefing provides participants with important information that could not appropriately be disclosed before or during a study and can correct misconceptions created by research procedures. Its requirements vary by ethics framework, so it should not be treated as universally mandatory after every study or optional after every deception.

PART 05 · SUBPART 19 · GUIDE 334

How Much Risk Can Deceptive Research Involve?

How Much Risk Can a Deceptive Study Ethically Involve?

Deception does not create permission to expose participants to whatever risks a scientifically valuable study requires. Some major frameworks restrict alterations to consent to minimal-risk research, while professional standards may impose additional limits on particular harms.

PART 05 · SUBPART 19 · GUIDE 333

Can Researchers Give Participants False Feedback?

Can Researchers Give Participants False Feedback About Their Performance or Behavior?

Researchers may sometimes provide fabricated performance or behavioral feedback as part of an approved deceptive design, but false feedback is active deception. Its ethical acceptability depends on scientific necessity, foreseeable harm, alternatives, ethics review, and appropriate correction of the false belief afterward.

PART 05 · SUBPART 19 · GUIDE 332

Are Placebos Deceptive?

Are Placebos a Form of Deception?

A placebo is not inherently a form of deception. Participants in a blinded trial can knowingly consent to the possibility of receiving a placebo without being told which intervention they receive, while undisclosed or falsely described placebo administration raises a different ethical issue.

PART 05 · SUBPART 19 · GUIDE 331

Deception When a Nondeceptive Alternative Exists

Can Deception Be Ethical When a Nondeceptive Study Could Answer the Same Question?

If a feasible, effective nondeceptive design can adequately answer the same research question, the ethical justification for deception becomes substantially weaker. Some professional standards, including APA’s ethics code for psychologists, explicitly make the absence of a feasible effective nondeceptive alternative a condition for using deception.

PART 05 · SUBPART 19 · GUIDE 330

When Is Research Deception Scientifically Necessary?

What Makes Deception Scientifically Necessary Rather Than Merely Convenient?

Deception is not scientifically necessary merely because it improves a study or makes data collection easier. A stronger justification shows that the research question cannot be answered adequately using a feasible, effective nondeceptive or less deceptive design.

PART 05 · SUBPART 19 · GUIDE 328

When Can You Withhold the Full Study Purpose?

When Is It Justifiable Not to Tell Participants the Full Purpose of a Study?

Researchers may sometimes withhold a study’s full purpose when prior disclosure would meaningfully compromise the research, but that is not a blanket exception to informed consent. The omission should be necessary, limited, appropriately reviewed, and consistent with applicable requirements for risk, participant welfare, and later disclosure.

PART 05 · SUBPART 19 · GUIDE 327

Is Withholding a Study’s Purpose Deception?

Is Withholding the Full Purpose of a Study Always Deception?

Not telling participants every objective or hypothesis is not automatically active deception. The key distinction is whether researchers merely withhold information or intentionally create a false or misleading understanding of the study.

PART 05 · SUBPART 19 · GUIDE 326

Deception vs. Incomplete Disclosure

Deception vs. Incomplete Disclosure: What’s the Difference?

Deception and incomplete disclosure both limit what participants know, but they do so differently. Deception typically involves false or misleading information, while incomplete disclosure withholds information without necessarily making a false statement.

PART 05 · SUBPART 19 · GUIDE 325

When Is Deception in Research Ethical?

Can Researchers Deceive Participants? When Is Deception in Research Ethical?

Researchers may sometimes use deception, but only under carefully justified and independently reviewed conditions. Ethical acceptability depends on necessity, risk, participants’ rights and welfare, available alternatives, and appropriate disclosure afterward.

PART 05 · SUBPART 18 · GUIDE 324

When a Data Breach May Pause a Study

Can a Data Breach Become Serious Enough to Require Pausing the Study?

A data breach does not automatically require stopping an entire study. A temporary pause may be appropriate when continuing recruitment, data collection, transfer, or access would expose participants or their information to an unresolved risk.

PART 05 · SUBPART 18 · GUIDE 323

Reporting a Research Data Breach

Who Must Be Told When a Research Data Breach Occurs?

A research data breach may need to be reported internally and, depending on its seriousness and the applicable rules, externally to regulators, affected participants, ethics bodies, sponsors, or partner institutions. These notification routes are related but not interchangeable.