Manuel B. Garcia

Manuel B. Garcia serves as the Senior Director for Educational Technology and Digital Learning at FEU Institute of Technology, Manila, Philippines. Read More

Contact Info

1607, FEU Tech Building,
P. Paredes St, Sampaloc,
Manila, Philippines
mbgarcia@feutech.edu.ph

Follow Me

The Complete Library

All Research Guides

Browse every published guide in the Researcher's Field Guide, including the complete research journey and supplemental collections, listed alphabetically for quick reference.

Complete Library

Every published guide

Showing 1,251–1,300 of 5,065 guides

5,065 guides
PART 05 · SUBPART 32 · GUIDE 572

Purchased Authorship and Research Misconduct

What Is Purchased Authorship, and Why Is It Research Misconduct?

Purchased authorship involves paying to receive scholarly authorship credit without satisfying the relevant contribution and accountability requirements. Understand why the practice misrepresents research, how it differs from legitimate paid collaboration, and why its classification as formal research misconduct depends on the applicable rules and evidence.

PART 05 · SUBPART 32 · GUIDE 571

Academic Paper Mills and Fraudulent Research Services

What Are Paper Mills, and How Do Fraudulent Research Services Operate?

Academic paper mills are organized services associated with producing or distributing fraudulent scholarly manuscripts and manipulating publication processes. Understand how these operations differ from legitimate research assistance, why their activities threaten the scholarly record, and what researchers should examine before trusting a commercial publication service.

PART 05 · SUBPART 32 · GUIDE 570

Third-Party Errors and Research Responsibility

Can a Researcher Blame a Third Party for an Error That Appears in the Final Study?

Researchers may identify contractors or consultants as the source of errors, but doing so does not automatically remove their responsibility for published findings. Learn how to distinguish the origin of an error from scholarly accountability, assess the adequacy of oversight, and determine when corrections or other action are necessary.

PART 05 · SUBPART 32 · GUIDE 569

Contractor Participant Data Confidentiality

Who Is Responsible When a Contractor Mishandles Confidential Participant Information?

When a research contractor mishandles confidential participant information, responsibility may extend beyond the individual who caused the incident. Learn how researchers should distinguish contractual, legal, and ethical obligations, respond to unauthorized disclosure, and prevent similar failures in outsourced research.

PART 05 · SUBPART 32 · GUIDE 568

Contractor-Fabricated Research Data

Who Is Responsible When a Contractor Fabricates Research Data?

When a contractor fabricates research data, responsibility cannot be assigned solely from the contractual relationship. Learn how researchers and institutions should distinguish the contractor's conduct from failures of oversight, preserve evidence, investigate the affected research, and correct unreliable findings.

PART 05 · SUBPART 32 · GUIDE 567

Ethical Participant Recruitment Companies

What Ethical Responsibilities Apply When a Recruitment Company Finds Participants for You?

Recruitment companies can help researchers reach eligible participants, but outsourcing recruitment does not transfer responsibility for ethical selection, privacy, consent, or participant protection. Learn what researchers should verify before engaging a provider and how to recognize recruitment practices that may compromise the study.

PART 05 · SUBPART 32 · GUIDE 566

Commercial Survey Panels for Research

Can You Trust Commercial Survey Panels for Academic Research?

Commercial survey panels can provide useful research data, but their reliability depends on recruitment, respondent verification, sampling, and quality-control procedures. Learn how to evaluate panel providers, recognize limitations of opt-in samples, and avoid treating demographic quotas or large sample sizes as guarantees of representativeness.

PART 05 · SUBPART 32 · GUIDE 565

Verifying Third-Party Data Collection

What Should You Verify When a Third Party Collects Your Research Data?

Hiring an external organization to collect research data does not eliminate the researcher's responsibility to assess their reliability. Learn how to verify participant recruitment, protocol compliance, data provenance, fieldwork documentation, and data quality without assuming that every irregularity indicates misconduct.

PART 05 · SUBPART 32 · GUIDE 564

Outsourcing Qualitative Coding and Transcription

Can Researchers Outsource Qualitative Coding or Transcription?

Researchers may outsource interview transcription and some qualitative coding activities, but these tasks differ in their interpretive demands. Learn how to protect participant confidentiality, evaluate transcription accuracy, supervise external coders, and maintain methodological accountability when qualitative work is delegated.

PART 05 · SUBPART 32 · GUIDE 563

Understanding Consultant Statistical Analysis

How Much Must You Understand About an Analysis Performed by a Consultant?

Researchers who hire statistical consultants do not necessarily need to master every mathematical derivation, but they must understand the decisions and limitations underlying their published findings. Learn what level of statistical understanding is necessary, how to question consultants effectively, and when an analysis requires further verification before publication.

PART 05 · SUBPART 32 · GUIDE 562

Outsourcing Statistical Analysis

Can Researchers Outsource Statistical Analysis Without Losing Responsibility for It?

Researchers may legitimately outsource statistical analysis, but delegation does not remove responsibility for methodological decisions, accurate reporting, or interpretation. Learn how to work with statistical consultants, evaluate analytical outputs, document decisions, and determine appropriate scholarly credit.

PART 05 · SUBPART 32 · GUIDE 561

Academic Editing vs. Substantive Writing

Editing vs. Substantive Writing: When Has an Editor Contributed Too Much?

Academic editing can improve a manuscript without changing its intellectual ownership. Yet the boundary becomes less clear when an editor develops arguments, interprets findings, or substantially rewrites scholarly content. Learn how to distinguish editorial assistance from substantive intellectual contribution and determine when acknowledgment, disclosure, or authorship consideration becomes necessary.

PART 05 · SUBPART 32 · GUIDE 560

Research Assistance vs. Ghostwriting

Research Assistance vs. Ghostwriting: Where Is the Ethical Boundary?

Research assistance and ghostwriting can involve similar tasks, but they differ in how intellectual contributions, responsibility, and authorship are represented. Learn when paid writing support is legitimate, when undisclosed contributions become problematic, and how researchers can establish ethical boundaries before engaging external writers.

PART 05 · SUBPART 32 · GUIDE 559

Outsourcing Academic Research

Can You Pay Someone Else to Write, Analyze, Collect, or Process Part of Your Research?

Researchers may legitimately pay qualified individuals or organizations to assist with data collection, transcription, analysis, editing, and other research tasks. The ethical boundary depends on transparency, appropriate attribution, methodological oversight, confidentiality, and whether the researcher remains accountable for the work presented as their own.

PART 05 · SUBPART 31 · GUIDE 558

Protecting Innocent Researchers From Allegations

Can Reporting a Genuine Concern Still Damage Innocent Researchers, and How Should Institutions Handle That Risk?

Even a genuine, good-faith research-integrity concern may cause professional harm to someone who has not committed misconduct. Understand how institutions should balance responsible reporting with confidentiality, impartial investigation, proportionate interim measures, and protection against unjustified reputational damage.

PART 05 · SUBPART 31 · GUIDE 557

Unfounded Research Misconduct Allegations

What Happens When an Allegation Turns Out to Be Wrong?

An allegation of research misconduct may be investigated and ultimately found unsupported. Understand the difference between an honest but mistaken concern, insufficient evidence, and a knowingly false accusation, including what institutions should do to protect researchers and address remaining problems in the research.

PART 05 · SUBPART 31 · GUIDE 556

When an Institution Refuses to Investigate Misconduct

What Should You Do if the Institution Appears Unwilling to Investigate a Serious Concern?

An institution's failure to investigate a serious research-integrity concern may raise questions about procedural compliance, jurisdiction, or institutional accountability. Learn how to distinguish legitimate preliminary dismissal from improper inaction, document the institutional response, and identify appropriate escalation routes without assuming that every refusal constitutes a cover-up.

PART 05 · SUBPART 31 · GUIDE 555

Research During a Misconduct Investigation

What Should Happen to the Research While a Misconduct Investigation Is Ongoing?

A research misconduct investigation does not automatically require every related project to stop. Understand when research may continue, when restrictions or suspension may be necessary, and how institutions should protect participants, preserve evidence, and maintain procedural fairness while allegations remain unresolved.

PART 05 · SUBPART 31 · GUIDE 554

Rights of Researchers Accused of Misconduct

What Rights Does a Researcher Accused of Misconduct Have?

Being accused of research misconduct does not establish guilt. Understand the procedural protections researchers may have during allegations, inquiries, and investigations, including notice, opportunities to respond, confidentiality, impartial assessment, and available review mechanisms.

PART 05 · SUBPART 31 · GUIDE 553

Research Misconduct Inquiry vs. Investigation

What Is the Difference Between an Inquiry and a Formal Research Misconduct Investigation?

A research misconduct inquiry and a formal investigation serve different purposes. Learn how institutions determine whether allegations warrant further examination, what each stage establishes, and why proceeding to an investigation does not mean misconduct has been proven.

PART 05 · SUBPART 31 · GUIDE 552

Who Determines Research Misconduct?

Who Decides Whether Fabrication, Falsification, or Plagiarism Actually Occurred?

Determining whether research misconduct occurred requires more than identifying an error or obtaining agreement among researchers. Learn who has authority to make formal findings, how evidence and culpability are assessed, and why institutional, regulatory, and editorial decisions must be distinguished.

PART 05 · SUBPART 31 · GUIDE 551

Research Misconduct Investigation Process

What Happens During a Research Misconduct Investigation?

A research misconduct investigation is a formal process for determining whether alleged wrongdoing occurred. Understand how allegations are assessed, evidence is preserved, inquiries and investigations differ, and institutions reach findings while protecting the rights of complainants and respondents.

PART 05 · SUBPART 31 · GUIDE 550

Anonymous Research Misconduct Reporting

Can You Report Research Misconduct Anonymously?

Anonymous reporting may allow researchers to raise misconduct concerns without identifying themselves, but anonymity can complicate investigations and may not prevent indirect identification. Learn when anonymous allegations can be assessed, how they differ from confidential reports, and what information makes them useful.

PART 05 · SUBPART 31 · GUIDE 549

Fear of Retaliation When Reporting Misconduct

What Should You Do if You Fear Retaliation for Reporting a Research Concern?

Fear of retaliation can make reporting research misconduct particularly difficult for students and early-career researchers. Learn how to evaluate professional risks, seek independent advice, preserve evidence, and identify reporting arrangements that offer appropriate protection without promising complete anonymity or immunity from adverse consequences.

PART 05 · SUBPART 31 · GUIDE 548

Research Whistleblower Retaliation

What Is Retaliation Against a Research Whistleblower?

Retaliation against a research whistleblower can involve employment decisions, academic disadvantage, exclusion from opportunities, or other adverse treatment connected to a protected report. Learn how retaliation is assessed, why timing alone may be insufficient, and what researchers should document when they suspect it.

PART 05 · SUBPART 31 · GUIDE 547

Research Whistleblower Protection

What Protections Do Research Whistleblowers Need?

Reporting research misconduct can expose researchers to professional, academic, and personal risks. Understand the safeguards whistleblowers need, why confidentiality alone is insufficient, and how institutions can protect good-faith reporting without compromising procedural fairness.

PART 05 · SUBPART 31 · GUIDE 546

Junior Researchers Reporting Senior Collaborators

Can a Junior Researcher Safely Raise Concerns About a Senior Collaborator?

Junior researchers may hesitate to question senior collaborators because of professional dependence, unequal authority, and fears of retaliation. Learn how to distinguish legitimate research concerns from interpersonal disagreements, preserve evidence, and choose reporting arrangements that protect both research integrity and procedural fairness.

PART 05 · SUBPART 31 · GUIDE 545

Reporting a Supervisor for Research Misconduct

Can a Student Report a Supervisor for Research Misconduct?

Students can raise research misconduct concerns about their supervisors, but the supervisory relationship may create particular risks. Learn how to report through appropriate institutional channels, protect research evidence, understand available safeguards, and distinguish a research-integrity allegation from an academic supervision dispute.

PART 05 · SUBPART 31 · GUIDE 544

Where to Report Research Misconduct

Who Should You Report Suspected Research Misconduct To?

Choosing the right reporting authority matters when research misconduct is suspected. Learn when to contact an institution, research integrity officer, journal, funder, or regulator, and how to report concerns responsibly when the usual reporting channel is unavailable or compromised.

PART 05 · SUBPART 31 · GUIDE 543

Confronting Suspected Research Misconduct

Should You Confront the Researcher Directly Before Reporting Suspected Misconduct?

Directly questioning a researcher about suspected misconduct may sometimes resolve an innocent misunderstanding, but it can also jeopardize evidence or expose the reporting person to retaliation. Learn when informal clarification may be appropriate and when confidential institutional advice should come first.

PART 05 · SUBPART 31 · GUIDE 542

Evidence Needed to Report Research Misconduct

How Much Evidence Should You Have Before Raising a Research Integrity Concern?

You do not necessarily need conclusive proof to raise a research misconduct concern. Learn what constitutes a sufficiently specific allegation, how to distinguish observations from speculation, and when further evidence gathering should be left to authorized investigators.

PART 05 · SUBPART 31 · GUIDE 541

What to Do About Suspected Research Misconduct

What Should You Do if You Suspect Research Misconduct?

Suspecting research misconduct does not mean you must prove wrongdoing before acting. Learn how to distinguish concerning evidence from speculation, preserve relevant records, raise concerns through appropriate channels, and protect the fairness of any subsequent investigation.

PART 05 · SUBPART 30 · GUIDE 540

Research Accountability After Leaving a Project

How Long Does a Researcher Remain Accountable for the Integrity of Work After Leaving the Project?

Leaving a research project does not necessarily end responsibility for work already performed or published. Understand how research accountability continues after resignation, graduation, retirement, or project completion, and why professional responsibility must be distinguished from legal and institutional obligations.

PART 05 · SUBPART 30 · GUIDE 539

Responsibility for Preserving Research Evidence

Who Is Responsible for Preserving the Evidence Behind a Completed Study?

Completing or publishing a study does not necessarily end the obligation to preserve its supporting evidence. Understand how responsibility is distributed among researchers, institutions, and record custodians, and what must remain available for future verification.

PART 05 · SUBPART 30 · GUIDE 538

Resolving Conflicting Research Records

What Should You Do When Two Researchers Have Different Records of What Happened?

Two researchers may document the same event differently without either account being deliberately misleading. Learn how to investigate conflicting research records, evaluate the available evidence, document reconciliation, and recognize when a discrepancy requires formal review.

PART 05 · SUBPART 30 · GUIDE 537

What to Do When Research Records Are Missing

What Should You Do When Important Research Records Are Missing?

Missing research records can undermine verification, interrupt analysis, and raise questions about the evidence supporting a study. Learn how to investigate missing records, preserve what remains, document the loss, and determine whether the research can still be defended.

PART 05 · SUBPART 30 · GUIDE 536

Research Records When Team Members Leave

What Should Happen to Research Records When a Team Member Leaves?

When a researcher leaves a project, the records supporting the work must remain accessible to authorized personnel and protected against loss or unauthorized use. Learn how to manage research handovers, clarify responsibilities, preserve evidence, and maintain continuity without compromising confidentiality or research integrity.

PART 05 · SUBPART 30 · GUIDE 535

Documenting Minor Research Decisions

Should Researchers Document Decisions That Seem Trivial at the Time?

Small research decisions can have consequences that become apparent only later. Learn which decisions deserve documentation, how to distinguish routine actions from consequential choices, and how to maintain a practical record without documenting every minor activity.

PART 05 · SUBPART 30 · GUIDE 534

What an Audit Trail Must Reconstruct

What Should an Audit Trail Allow Someone Else to Reconstruct?

A useful audit trail should allow an authorized reviewer to trace research findings back to their supporting evidence and consequential decisions. Learn what must be reconstructable, how much detail is sufficient, and how to test whether your documentation works.

PART 05 · SUBPART 30 · GUIDE 533

Research Audit Trails and Integrity

What Is an Audit Trail, and Why Does Research Integrity Depend on One?

A research audit trail documents how evidence, decisions, and analyses developed throughout a study. Understand what belongs in an audit trail, how it differs from ordinary recordkeeping, and why its value extends beyond regulatory compliance.

PART 05 · SUBPART 30 · GUIDE 532

Deleting Incorrect Research Records

Is It Ever Acceptable to Delete an Incorrect Research Record?

An incorrect research record does not automatically become disposable. Understand when deletion may be permissible, why preserving original evidence matters, and how to distinguish legitimate disposal from the concealment of research errors.

PART 05 · SUBPART 30 · GUIDE 531

Documenting Corrections to Research Records

How Should Corrections to Research Records Be Documented?

Research records sometimes contain mistakes, but correcting them should not erase the history of what was originally documented. Learn how to make transparent, traceable corrections that preserve the evidentiary value of your research.

PART 05 · SUBPART 30 · GUIDE 530

Changing Research Records

Can Research Records Be Changed After They Have Been Created?

Research records are not necessarily immutable, but legitimate changes should preserve the integrity and history of the record. Learn how corrections, additions, and updates differ from improper alteration.

PART 05 · SUBPART 30 · GUIDE 529

Who Owns Research Records?

Who Owns Laboratory Notebooks, Field Notes, and Research Records?

The researcher who creates a laboratory notebook, field note, or dataset does not necessarily own it personally. Ownership, custody, access, intellectual property, and authorship are separate questions governed by institutional policies and agreements.

PART 05 · SUBPART 30 · GUIDE 528

How Much Research Documentation Is Enough?

How Much Documentation Is Enough to Defend What You Actually Did?

Research documentation should be detailed enough to establish what actually happened without becoming a record of every trivial action. Learn how to judge when the evidence is sufficient.

PART 05 · SUBPART 30 · GUIDE 525

What Is an Adequate Research Record?

What Counts as an Adequate Research Record?

An adequate research record is not simply a large collection of files. It should provide reliable, interpretable, and traceable evidence of what happened and support reconstruction of consequential research steps.

PART 05 · SUBPART 29 · GUIDE 523

Undeclared Conflicts After Research

What Happens if You Discover an Undeclared Conflict After the Research Is Complete?

An undeclared conflict discovered after a study is complete should be reported promptly rather than quietly added to future disclosures. The next step is to determine what should have been disclosed, whether the conflict affected the research, and what correction, retrospective review, management, or mitigation is required.