Manuel B. Garcia

Manuel B. Garcia serves as the Senior Director for Educational Technology and Digital Learning at FEU Institute of Technology, Manila, Philippines. Read More

Contact Info

1607, FEU Tech Building,
P. Paredes St, Sampaloc,
Manila, Philippines
mbgarcia@feutech.edu.ph

Follow Me

The Complete Library

All Research Guides

Browse every published guide in the Researcher's Field Guide, including the complete research journey and supplemental collections, listed alphabetically for quick reference.

Complete Library

Every published guide

Showing 551–600 of 5,065 guides

5,065 guides
PART 0D · SUBPART 45 · GUIDE 646

AI Recommendations of Discontinued Journals

Can Generative AI Recommend Discontinued or Delisted Journals?

Generative AI may recommend journals that have ceased publication or lost indexing coverage. Learn how to distinguish discontinued journals from delisted titles and verify their current status before submitting a manuscript.

PART 0D · SUBPART 45 · GUIDE 645

AI-Generated Nonexistent Journals

Can Generative AI Recommend Academic Journals That Do Not Exist?

Generative AI can recommend convincing academic journals that do not exist, sometimes accompanied by fabricated publishers or indexing claims. Learn how to recognize these errors and verify journal identities before submission.

PART 0D · SUBPART 45 · GUIDE 644

AI Manuscript-to-Journal Scope Matching

Can Generative AI Match a Research Manuscript to a Journal’s Scope?

Generative AI can compare a manuscript with a journal's aims and scope, but sharing a research topic does not guarantee editorial suitability. Learn how to assess disciplinary fit, methodological expectations, and the manuscript's actual contribution.

PART 0D · SUBPART 44 · GUIDE 641

Disclosing AI Use in Reviewer Responses

Does AI Assistance in a Response-to-Reviewers Letter Require Disclosure?

AI assistance in a response-to-reviewers letter may require disclosure depending on the journal's policies and the nature of the assistance. Learn how to distinguish routine language correction from substantive drafting, where disclosure belongs, and how to avoid unnecessary or incomplete declarations.

PART 0D · SUBPART 44 · GUIDE 639

Uploading Confidential Reviewer Comments to AI

Can Confidential Reviewer Comments Be Uploaded to an AI Tool?

Reviewer comments may contain confidential editorial information and unpublished research details. Uploading them to an AI tool can create disclosure and data-handling risks, even when the authors received the comments legitimately. Learn when processing may be permitted, what safeguards matter, and why removing names does not necessarily eliminate confidentiality concerns.

PART 0D · SUBPART 44 · GUIDE 638

AI Overstatement in Responses to Reviewers

Can Generative AI Overstate How Fully a Reviewer Concern Was Addressed?

Generative AI may describe a partially addressed reviewer concern as fully resolved, even when the manuscript contains only limited clarification or acknowledgment. Learn how to distinguish genuine resolution from partial responses, verify claims against the revised manuscript, and avoid overstating the significance of revisions.

PART 0D · SUBPART 44 · GUIDE 637

Invented Manuscript Changes in AI Reviewer Responses

Can Generative AI Invent Manuscript Changes While Drafting a Response to Reviewers?

Generative AI can invent manuscript changes while drafting a response-to-reviewers letter, including nonexistent analyses, revised sections, citations, and page references. Learn why these hallucinations occur, how they differ from future revision promises, and how authors can verify the response against the actual manuscript.

PART 0D · SUBPART 44 · GUIDE 636

AI Promises of Uncompleted Manuscript Revisions

Can Generative AI Accidentally Promise a Manuscript Revision That Was Never Made?

Generative AI may draft responses promising additional analyses, methodological clarifications, or manuscript changes that authors never completed. Learn how these commitments arise, why they can mislead editors and reviewers, and how to distinguish planned revisions from verified work.

PART 0D · SUBPART 44 · GUIDE 635

AI for Explaining Reviewer Disagreement

Can Generative AI Help Explain Why an Author Disagrees With a Reviewer?

Authors may reasonably disagree with peer reviewers when recommendations are unsupported, methodologically inappropriate, or inconsistent with the study's objectives. Generative AI can help articulate a respectful response, but the scientific justification must come from the authors and be verified against the manuscript and relevant evidence.

PART 0D · SUBPART 44 · GUIDE 634

AI for Polite Responses to Reviewers

Can Generative AI Suggest Polite Responses to Difficult Reviewer Comments?

Generative AI can help authors respond professionally to harsh, confusing, or demanding reviewer comments. However, politeness should not come at the expense of scientific accuracy. Learn how to acknowledge criticism, explain revisions, and disagree respectfully without making unsupported concessions or promising work that was never completed.

PART 0D · SUBPART 44 · GUIDE 633

AI for Identifying Reviewer Analysis Requests

Can Generative AI Identify Which Reviewer Comments Require New Analyses?

Generative AI may help identify reviewer comments that appear to request new statistical or qualitative analyses. However, authors must distinguish actual analytical requirements from requests for clarification, assess whether additional analyses are justified, and avoid conducting unnecessary or misleading tests merely to satisfy generated revision plans.

PART 0D · SUBPART 44 · GUIDE 632

AI for Reviewer Comment Revision Planning

Can Generative AI Organize Reviewer Comments Into a Revision Action Plan?

Generative AI can help researchers turn lengthy reviewer reports into a structured revision action plan. Learn how to preserve every comment, identify overlapping requests, distinguish scientific revisions from editorial changes, and verify that the final plan accurately represents what reviewers asked.

PART 0D · SUBPART 44 · GUIDE 631

AI-Assisted Responses to Peer Reviewers

Can Generative AI Help Draft Responses to Peer-Reviewer Comments?

Generative AI can help authors organize reviewer comments and draft clear, professional responses during manuscript revision. However, it may invent completed revisions, overstate how concerns were addressed, or promise analyses that were never conducted. Learn how to use AI responsibly while keeping every response consistent with the revised manuscript.

PART 0D · SUBPART 43 · GUIDE 630

Human Judgment in Academic Peer Review

Which Parts of Peer Review Require Irreducible Human Judgment?

Some peer-review tasks may benefit from AI assistance, but evaluating scientific significance, methodological appropriateness, evidentiary strength, and the proportionality of criticism requires accountable human judgment. Learn where automation reaches its limits and why meaningful oversight is more than approving generated recommendations.

PART 0D · SUBPART 43 · GUIDE 629

AI Bias in Peer-Review Decisions

Can AI Bias Affect Peer-Review Decisions?

AI-assisted peer review may introduce or reinforce biases affecting which manuscripts receive favorable assessments. Learn how methodological conventions, language patterns, research contexts, and automation bias can shape AI-generated evaluations, and how journals can test for unfair differences.

PART 0D · SUBPART 43 · GUIDE 628

Disclosing AI Use in Editorial Assessment

Should Authors Be Told When AI Was Used in Editorial Assessment?

Authors may have legitimate reasons to know when AI materially influences editorial assessment, particularly rejection or revision decisions. Learn how disclosure differs from permission, why routine automated checks require different consideration, and how journals can make AI-assisted editorial decisions more transparent and accountable.

PART 0D · SUBPART 43 · GUIDE 627

AI in Editorial Manuscript Evaluation

Can Journal Editors Use AI to Evaluate Submitted Research Manuscripts?

Journal editors may use AI to support selected manuscript-screening and editorial tasks, but automated assessments can introduce confidentiality, accuracy, and fairness concerns. Learn which applications may be appropriate, how editorial AI differs from reviewer AI use, and why consequential publication decisions require accountable human judgment.

PART 0D · SUBPART 43 · GUIDE 626

Disclosing AI Use in Peer Review

Should Reviewers Disclose AI Use to the Journal?

Peer reviewers should follow journal requirements for disclosing generative AI assistance, and disclosure may be expected even when AI is used only for language editing. Learn what should be reported, why permission must come before use, and how to distinguish transparent assistance from unauthorized delegation.

PART 0D · SUBPART 43 · GUIDE 625

Confident but Irrelevant AI Reviewer Comments

Can Generative AI Produce Confident but Irrelevant Peer-Review Comments?

Generative AI can produce technically convincing peer-review comments that are irrelevant to a manuscript's design, objectives, or findings. Learn how to recognize misplaced criticisms, distinguish methodological alternatives from genuine weaknesses, and prevent unsupported AI feedback from influencing editorial decisions.

PART 0D · SUBPART 43 · GUIDE 624

Understanding AI-Generated Peer-Review Criticisms

Should Reviewers Rely on AI-Generated Criticisms They Do Not Personally Understand?

Peer reviewers should not include AI-generated criticisms they cannot personally understand or defend. Learn why technical language can conceal incorrect recommendations, how to investigate unfamiliar concerns, and when specialist expertise is more appropriate than AI assistance.

PART 0D · SUBPART 43 · GUIDE 623

AI-Generated Peer Reviews

Can Generative AI Produce a Peer Review From a Research Manuscript?

Generative AI can produce text resembling a scholarly peer-review report, but that does not establish a reliable evaluation of the manuscript. Learn why generated criticisms may be inaccurate, how confidentiality and journal policies restrict use, and why reviewers cannot delegate their scholarly responsibility.

PART 0D · SUBPART 43 · GUIDE 622

AI for Improving Peer-Review Comments

Can Generative AI Help Improve the Wording of Peer-Review Comments?

Generative AI may help reviewers make their comments clearer, more constructive, and professionally worded. However, even language editing can introduce confidentiality risks or change the meaning of a criticism. Learn when such assistance may be permitted and how reviewers should verify the final report.

PART 0D · SUBPART 43 · GUIDE 621

AI and Statistical Claims in Peer Review

Can Generative AI Help Check Statistical Claims During Peer Review?

Generative AI may help reviewers identify questionable statistical claims, but it can also miscalculate, misinterpret results, or recommend inappropriate analyses. Learn how to distinguish useful statistical questions from verified errors while protecting manuscript confidentiality.

PART 0D · SUBPART 43 · GUIDE 620

AI and Methodological Problems in Peer Review

Can Generative AI Help Identify Methodological Problems During Peer Review?

Generative AI may suggest methodological weaknesses worth investigating during peer review, but its criticisms can be incorrect, generic, or irrelevant. Learn when AI assistance may be appropriate, how to verify suggested concerns, and why manuscript confidentiality and independent reviewer judgment remain essential.

PART 0D · SUBPART 43 · GUIDE 619

AI and Peer-Review Confidentiality

Does Using AI on an Unpublished Manuscript Violate Peer-Review Confidentiality?

Using AI during peer review can violate confidentiality when unpublished manuscript information is disclosed to an unauthorized system. Learn why confidentiality extends beyond uploading PDFs, how publisher policies differ, and what safeguards reviewers must observe.

PART 0D · SUBPART 43 · GUIDE 618

Uploading Confidential Manuscripts to AI

Can a Peer Reviewer Upload a Confidential Manuscript to an AI Tool?

Peer reviewers generally should not upload confidential manuscripts to external AI tools without explicit journal authorization and appropriate safeguards. Learn why manuscript confidentiality applies to AI services, what permission actually means, and how to avoid unauthorized disclosure.

PART 0D · SUBPART 43 · GUIDE 617

Generative AI in Peer Review Writing

Can Generative AI Help Write a Peer Review?

Generative AI may help reviewers organize and refine their comments, but its use is subject to journal policies, confidentiality obligations, and independent scholarly judgment. Learn which forms of assistance may be appropriate and why reviewers remain responsible for their reports.

PART 0D · SUBPART 42 · GUIDE 616

When AI Methods Are Too Unstable

When Is an AI-Assisted Method Too Unstable for Scientific Use?

An AI-assisted method may be too unstable for scientific use when output variability undermines measurement validity or changes the conclusions. Learn how to recognize consequential instability, evaluate its effects, and decide when an AI method should be revised, restricted, or replaced.

PART 0D · SUBPART 42 · GUIDE 615

Reproducibility With Probabilistic AI

What Does Reproducibility Mean When AI Output Is Probabilistic?

Probabilistic AI outputs challenge the assumption that reproducibility always requires identical responses. Learn how researchers can evaluate distributions, measurement stability, and scientific conclusions while distinguishing reproducibility from accuracy and validity.

PART 0D · SUBPART 42 · GUIDE 614

Rerunning AI-Assisted Research Tasks

Should Important AI-Assisted Research Tasks Be Rerun Multiple Times?

Important AI-assisted research tasks may need repeated execution to establish whether their outputs are sufficiently stable. Learn when rerunning is worthwhile, how to design meaningful tests, and why repeated agreement does not necessarily establish scientific accuracy.

PART 0D · SUBPART 42 · GUIDE 613

Testing AI Coding and Classification Stability

How Do Researchers Test the Stability of AI-Assisted Coding or Classification?

AI-assisted coding stability should be tested rather than assumed from a few consistent outputs. Learn how to design repeated-run evaluations, measure classification agreement, examine errors, and determine whether AI-generated codes are sufficiently dependable for research.

PART 0D · SUBPART 42 · GUIDE 612

Deterministic Workflows With Nondeterministic AI

Can Researchers Build a Deterministic Workflow Around a Nondeterministic AI Model?

A nondeterministic AI model can be incorporated into a controlled research workflow without requiring every generated response to be identical. Learn how structured outputs, validation, archived records, and deterministic downstream procedures can improve reproducibility while preserving the distinction between computational consistency and scientific validity.

PART 0D · SUBPART 42 · GUIDE 611

Reproducing Research Without the Original AI Model

How Do You Reproduce an AI-Assisted Analysis When the Original AI Model Is No Longer Available?

When the original AI model is no longer accessible, exact regeneration may be impossible, but important parts of an AI-assisted analysis can still be verified. Learn how to reconstruct the analytical record, reproduce downstream calculations, and evaluate replacement models without overstating reproducibility.

PART 0D · SUBPART 42 · GUIDE 610

Archiving AI Outputs in Research

Should AI Outputs Used in Research Be Archived?

AI outputs that influence research data, analysis, or conclusions should generally be preserved as part of the research record. Learn what to archive, how to protect confidential information, and why saving outputs matters even when the original AI model remains available.

PART 0D · SUBPART 42 · GUIDE 609

Research Prompts as Analysis Code

Should Research Prompts Be Treated Like Analysis Code?

AI prompts can function as analytical instructions when they determine how research data are classified, extracted, or interpreted. Learn when prompts should be documented, tested, and version-controlled like research code.

PART 0D · SUBPART 42 · GUIDE 608

Recording AI Model Settings

Should Researchers Record Temperature and Other AI Model Settings?

Researchers should record temperature and other relevant AI settings when those settings may affect research outputs. Learn which parameters matter, what they control, and how to document configurations that are not accessible.

PART 0D · SUBPART 42 · GUIDE 607

AI Model Versioning in Research

Should Researchers Treat an AI Model Version Like a Software Version?

AI model versions should be documented as research dependencies, much like software versions. However, model names, snapshots, and hosted services introduce additional complications that researchers need to understand.

PART 0D · SUBPART 42 · GUIDE 606

AI Model Updates and Research Reproducibility

Can AI Model Updates Make an AI-Assisted Research Workflow Impossible to Reproduce?

AI model updates can make an earlier research workflow difficult or impossible to reproduce exactly, especially when the original model is no longer accessible. Learn what changes, which research results remain verifiable, and how to prepare for model retirement.

PART 0D · SUBPART 42 · GUIDE 605

Do Identical AI Prompts Guarantee Results?

Does Using the Same AI Prompt Guarantee the Same Result?

Using the same AI prompt does not guarantee the same result. Learn what must remain constant for AI outputs to be repeatable, why deterministic settings have limitations, and how researchers should verify consequential outputs.

PART 0D · SUBPART 42 · GUIDE 604

Why AI Prompts Produce Different Answers

Why Can the Same AI Prompt Produce Different Answers?

The same AI prompt can produce different answers because language models may use probabilistic generation, changing model configurations, and variable execution environments. Understanding these differences helps researchers evaluate the reliability of AI-assisted methods.

PART 0D · SUBPART 42 · GUIDE 603

AI-Assisted Research Reproducibility

Can AI-Assisted Research Be Reproducible?

AI-assisted research can be reproducible, but saving a prompt is rarely enough. Learn how model versions, settings, archived outputs, and independent validation affect the reproducibility of AI-supported research workflows.

PART 0D · SUBPART 41 · GUIDE 602

Retaining AI-Use Records in Research Archives

When Should Records of AI Use Be Retained With the Research Archive?

AI-use records may need to be retained with the research archive when they materially support research procedures, evidence, or findings. Learn how to determine which records belong in the archive, apply institutional retention requirements, and distinguish long-term preservation from unnecessary storage of incidental AI interactions.

PART 0D · SUBPART 41 · GUIDE 601

Preserving AI Interactions for Research

How Do Researchers Preserve an AI Interaction if the Provider May Later Delete or Change It?

AI providers may change models, interfaces, and conversation-retention arrangements, making historical interactions difficult to reconstruct. Learn how to preserve consequential prompts, responses, metadata, and verification records in a secure research archive without relying exclusively on provider-hosted histories.

PART 0D · SUBPART 41 · GUIDE 600

AI Conversations as Research Audit Trails

Can AI Conversations Become Part of a Research Audit Trail?

AI conversations can contribute to a research audit trail when they document consequential prompts, outputs, and decisions. Learn why chat histories alone are insufficient, how to connect interactions to research records, and what makes an AI-assisted audit trail credible, secure, and useful.

PART 0D · SUBPART 41 · GUIDE 599

How Much AI Documentation Is Enough?

How Much Documentation of AI Use Is Enough for Research?

Adequate AI-use documentation depends on how substantially AI influenced the research and what evidence may be needed to reconstruct consequential decisions. Learn how to balance transparency, reproducibility, confidentiality, and practical recordkeeping without preserving every interaction unnecessarily.

PART 0D · SUBPART 41 · GUIDE 598

Documenting Rejected AI Suggestions

Should Researchers Record AI Suggestions They Rejected?

Rejected AI suggestions may be worth documenting when they influence consequential research decisions. Learn when discarded recommendations form part of the research audit trail, how to record reasons for rejection, and why researchers need not preserve every unsuccessful AI interaction.

PART 0D · SUBPART 41 · GUIDE 597

Documenting AI Output Verification

Should Researchers Record How AI Outputs Were Verified?

Researchers should document how consequential AI outputs were verified, particularly when they influence research methods, evidence, analysis, or findings. Learn what constitutes meaningful verification, how to preserve supporting evidence, and why claiming that AI-generated content was reviewed is not equivalent to demonstrating that it was checked.